Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
How two claims that ------ (A) RtrDeo3-law-draft will damage India (B) but same RtrDeo3-law-draft plus 'officer must maintain a good website' clause will hugely benefit India !! ----- are meant to ruin RTR/Jury movement !!
.
First lets say that claim-A and claim-B are correct. Then will the saviour "good website" come within 1 day after law-draft with good website is printed? NO. In fact, it wont come even in weeks. In fact the people who made claim that "draft with website clause is good" themselves also admitted that a "good" website wont come for several weeks !!
.
Hence the claim maker himself INDIRECTLY puts s claim that "(RtrDeo3-law-draft plus good website clause) will ALDO also damage India for several months" !!
.
So next claim can be --- "See, without 'good' website RtrDeo3-law-draft will damage India. So we all activists should first focus on getting good-website-law-draft passed and IMPLEMENTED, and ONLY after good-website-law-draft is IMPLEMENTED, we should talk about RtrDeo3-law-draft's other clauses" !!!
.
So I see request all recallists to see how much DAMAGE this "officer must maintain good website" clause will make if it is added to RtrDeo3 or other drafts. That too when one sayd "without such website, RtrDeo3 will damage India" !!
.
IOW, the whole argument that "without good website, RtrDeo3 and other RTR/Jury draft will ruin India" automatically means that "till such website comes, Rtr?Jury clauses should NOT be printed or should be kept inactive" !!! And it will take months to make such "good" website, after "good website" clauses are printed in Gazette!!
.
IOW, this argument as well as this clause is ONLY meant to kill RTR/Jury movement.
.
-----
.
Now will RtrDeo3-law-draft with "good website clause" ruin India, if it is printed in Gazette today? NO. Imo, India will benefit.
.
First, for several months, "RtrDeoe-law-draft without website clause and RtrDeo3-law-draft WITH website clause" will have same effect for first several months because good websites wont come for several weeks.
.
Because if this law is printed today, with or WITHOUT "good website" clause, it will take weeks/months for good websites to come with ALL relevant details, that too all historical details.
.
Because govt website is NOT only source of information. The best source of information since ages has been direct experience and word of mouth i.e. information from people you personally know. To that, one can add all information DEO can put on his own private website and also send to voters via FB/WhatsApp/TCP. Paidmediamen's influence works only when govt officer has NO channel to communicate. But TCP creates a channel for every DEO to DIRECTLY communicate with voters. So with all this communication channels, paidmedia's influence will be mnuch lesser what it is today. And with or without clause that "officer must create a good website" , DEOs will improve their private websites as well as official govt websites. So all claims that in absence of "good website clauses", Rtr/Jury processes will get derailed is farce.