Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
Why good govt websites and expense reports will be pretty much useless in taking some MOST imp decisions
.
Many life and death issues in governance are core ideological. And voters need to electa person to take some of these important decisions. And here, voters need to guess what ideology/mentality he has, and then keep/replace him. And in many life-death issues, information on official websites or integrity in expense reporting will be least of needed points
.
eg consider level of MSLW ( = maths/science/law/weapon-use) education in children of poor. The elitemen would always want Education Minister and DEOs who would ruin maths/science/law/weapon education in poors' kids as far as possible. While commons would need to have a Minister/DEO who wishes to promote maximal maths/science/law/weapons education.
.
Now elitemen will always manage to find a fame hungry person, who is willing to ruin maths/science/law/weapons education of kids of poor. And fame hungry persons are always very systematic about expense reporting (eg Duratma Gandhi). Plus, he will get ample support, staff help and 100% while legal funds from elitemen to promote his campaigns.
.
And such fame hungry people are also always very prompt in ensuring that all details are given in books and disclosures correctly.
.
So if one look at BOOKS , be expenses books or other books, or websites that show these books, then books/websites of elitemen-agent will look very neat and clean. Whereas at core, that person will be completely defunct, fame hungry and anti-common, pro-elitemen
.
Same way, consider taxation rules. An elitemen agent will support regressive taxes like GST while pro-common person will support wealth tax. Here too, elitemen will manage to find a fame hungry person who is willing to support GST and find many creative arguments against wealth tax. And here too, that fame hungry person will ensure that all his expense books and other books are very neat and clean and all reporting/disclosures are prompt and proper. And he will also manage to
.
So how can voters decide which DEO/Minister is better/worse on issue of maths/science education for poors' kids? How can voters come to know and decide that wealth tax is less bad than GST, and decide which exact wealth tax law-draft to take?
.
This where TRUE ACTIVISTS and true activism helps and TCP can help. And this is where psuedo-activism will be also at highest !!!
.
The true activists will need to prepare proposals which improve MSLW education of poors' kids, and using TCP prove supporter-count of the proposals. And elitemen-agents will work their best to sabotage these proposals using all means, including adding minor VARIATIONS after VARIATIONS in the proposals. eg say one makes a proposal to improve PSLW education that indeed improve MSLW education. Then elitemen agent will come up with VARIATION saying "this PSLW proposal will ruin India , but same proposal with Geography education will benefit India". And next will say "this PSLW education proposal will ruin India, but same proposal with good website clause will benefit India" !! And new wealth tax draft is good because if it has clauses for good websites". And so on.
.
And here activists will need to use mind and analyse, and act.
.
Outcomes will depend on what steps activists take, and what steps they decide not to take.
.
But all in all, my point is --- a large number of CORE issues such who should get mineral royalty, whether tax should be GST or wealth tax or whether education should focus on history/morals or maths/science/law/weapon etc will depend heavily on ideology of the persons, that voters appoint. And these are all OPEN issues where nothing is hidden, because all Gazette drafts that these apex people will print will come in public anyway. And details like expense reports and full disclsosures of tiny activities will have no value. And activists will need to inform voters about proposals, and elitemen-agents will throw counter-proposals including endless streams of MINOR VARIATIONS !! Here, all information will be pretty much publicly available. And outcome will depend on steps activists take and steps they decide not to take, not on quality of govt websites. Because all information will be publicly known to all.