Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

Interesting question dealing with libertarianism (anarchocapitalism type)
.
First, a less important question
.
say there is rain making technology, which will increase rainfall and thats benefits all. But the technology can ensure that more rain will fall in 100 km * 100 km area, but not exactly where. And each person has farm of of 1000 meters * 1000 meters, and there are 100*10000 people in that area.
.
Now there are rainfall increasing techniques which cause zero damage to environment (eg increasing moisture, using 100% organic precipitants etc)
.
Now say 80% people agree to pay fees (or taxes) for this rain services. And 20% say they dont want to pay for this extra rain at al.
.
Then either these 2000 will get rain for free for these 2000 have to be taxed against their will.
.
Now question is --- is it UNFAIR to tax these 20% ?
.
As per anarchocapitalism is UNFAIR and as per RECALLISTS, it is FAIR
.
Anarchocapitalist answer is --- NO. None should be taxed against his will.
.
Also, these 20% should be allowed to sue 80% for damages. Because the ARTIFICIAL rainwater, caused by these 80% trespassed on their property against their freewill !!! Lets leave this trespassing argument away from now. The "should all be taxed for rain" problem alone is serious enough.
.
------------------------------------------
.
Now, second a less important question (added later), is more realistic
.
Pls google "rockfall protection mesh". Pls click IMAGES
.
Now say a town of 10000 is facing problem of rockfalls. A person proposed a mesh across mountains to reduce the damages. Say 8000 people agree to pay and 2000 say "I dont want benefits of rockfall reducing mesh and I also dont want to pay", Now should these 8000 force remaining 2000 to pay?
.
Recallist answer is plain simple YES
.
Anarchocapitalist Libertarian answer is --- NO
.
Now to a neutral audience Anarchocapitalist Libertarian may look appealing and Anarchocapitalist Libertarian can always make recallist look bad . His claim will be "see recallists are immoral people who are proposing that theft should be done on these 2000 disagreeing people" !!!
.
So recallists need to phrase counter arguments
.
-------
.
Now the REAL important question.
.
Consider the real problem India is facing --- possible military attacks from usuk-weapon-manufacturing-elitemen (Rothschilde, Gates etc) and Chinese and Pakistainies. USUK would invade India via Pakistan and not directly for now (eg Kargil) . But may invade directly too like they did in Afghanistan and Iraq,.
.
Now consider someone living in center of India. Now Pakistanies or Chinese will not invade him directly. Pakistanies or Chinese will first invade borders states and people there, and then if border states loose , then surely they may later invade the central states and southern states
.
Now say out of 90 crore voters, say 20 crore voters say "I dont want Indian Military to protect me from chinese and pakistanies and usuk, and so I dont want to pay taxes for Military", And remaining 70 crore voters say "we will pay taxes because we want protection"
.
Now as per some libertarain anarcho-capitalists , it is immoral to tax these 20 crore !!!
.
Recallists solution is --- tax all, and disregard opposition of these 20 crore.
.
Now libertarians solution is -- dont tax these 20 croe.
.
And they can make look recallist look bad, Their claim will be "see , these racllists are immoral people who are advoicating theft on 20 crore just because they have consent of 70 crore"
.
So question to recallists is --- what statements do you want to make before the neutral audience?