Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
Libertarianism ideology is created only to waste away time of activists in India - post #003
.
Ask following question to any libertarian. And then decide based on his answer
.
(Q03) The River Water Question
.
( similar to pond question at https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10157378175791922 )
.
Say there is a river 1000 km long. We divide it into 100 segments of 10 km long each for purpose of this question. Each segment has 10000 people.
.
Now if each persons draws 100k liters a year, then everyone will get 100k liters
.
But if some persons draw more, then at least some persons IN LAST segments will get less
.
Now say person in first segment draw 200k liters a year. And rest all draw 100k liters. Now persons in segment$ 2 to 99 will NOT be effected !! But persons in last 100th segment will have zero water !!!
.
And likewise, if persons in first 25 segments draw 200k liters a year, and next 50 segments draw 100k liters a year, then last 25 segments will have zero water
.
Now say India becomes libertarian as on 21-oct-2020, wed, midnight 12.01am
.
How do libertarians propose to address the limits? Or , should there no limit on water drawing?
.
The illibertarian recallists solution is --- PM will appoint National Water Meter Officer , who can be recalled / replaced by 90 crore voters. And Jury System will decide small disutes. And limit of 100k per year = say 83k liters per month will enforced on all. And each person can SELL his monthly quota to anyone. For details, pls see article I wrote in year year 2001 at rahulmehta . com / eas01 . or see link in 1st comment
.
But this solution enforce majority will on minority against their consent.
.
The people in 1st segment will oppose this solution as --- who gave moral rights to restrict my freedom to draw more 100k liters ?
.
How do libertarians propose to address the limits? Or , should there no limit on water drawing?
.
How will private police company in last segment know who is drawing more in first segment? And how will private police company in 100th segment go on war with private police company of 1st segment? And Expect zero co-operation from people and private police companies of first 50 segments. They are not effected by overdrawing of water in first few segments
.
So how do libertarians propose to handle this question?
.
Pls ask them