Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

(Q02) The Pond Question - pls ask libertarian to give libertarian solution to the problem
.
Following SECOND question that Imo convinces neutral audience that libertarianism is just a timepass created to take activists AWAY from laws that would strengthe Indian military such as JuryCourt / wealth tax / recall
.
Say there is town with 10000 people and there is only one water source --- a pond. Every year, it gets biliion liters by rain or 100k liters per person per year.
.
As per libertarian ethics and system , how should 10k people divide water ?
.
The question is most fundamental question in society. Many products in nature have zero labor and yet have value. E.g. coal mining cost is often below Rs 300 per tonne and same coal fetches Rs 3000 per tonne or 4 times. Same for a huge number of natural resources.
.
Most wars were fought for water and fertile land. And ww1 was fought for coal and iron. ww2 for iron and petrol. And gulf war for petrol. And Libya was looted for lithium and petrol. And long list.
..
So in that town of 10k people , how should water rights be distributed?
.
Recallists answer is --- activists should force that all gets rights of 100k liter per year and let them sell rights.
.
The libertarian answer prima facie goes against recallists answer. That's not new. Recallists are illibertaian anyway.
.
As per Libertarians, pond should be privatized and private owner should decide rates. Say there are 100 owners . Then what will stop 9900 from using violence? I will let libertarians answer all questions.
.
------------
.
If you think that question is worthy, then pls ask question to libertarian you know