Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

What is the End-Use Monitoring Agreement for complex weapons like Mirage or Rafeal fighter planes and SPICE missiles ?
.
A must read article on rediff -- http://news.rediff.com/special/2009/jul/22/end-use-monitoring-agreement-a-factsheet.htm
.
-------------------------
.
What is the End-Use Monitoring Agreement?
.
22-jul-2009
.
The US had been pressing India to sign three agreements related to defense cooperation:
.
1. End Use Monitoring Agreement (EUMA).
.
2. Communications Interoperability and Security Memorandum of Agreement (CIS MoA).
.
3. Mutual Logistic Support Agreement (MLSA).
.
All these agreements contain a series of restrictive clauses.
.
...........
EUMA CLAUSES
.
Yet, the US has succeeded in imposing the End Use Monitoring Agreement (EUMA) on India. The EUMA is highly controversial.

Some of its clauses may not be a subject of concern, such as prohibitions on second-hand sales without approval of the United States. Its contentious clauses impose restrictions on what India may do with the equipment it buys from the USA.
.
EUMA will allow the US to periodically carry out an inspection and inventory of all articles transferred to India. In the negotiations, India strenuously objected to physical inspection and instead sought an inspection of the records and other measures in place. In the end, the Americans had their way, but it was agreed that the physical inspection would be done at a time and place granted by India. Supplying-State officials, in any case, would need visas and other assistance from the recipient State, including about the location of the equipment, to carry out an inspection.
.
Under the terms of EUMA, India cannot modify the purchased defence article or system in any form.
.
Also, to prevent the buyer country from freeing itself from dependency on the United States for maintenance, EUMA restricts India from getting US-origin defence equipment serviced by any another country without prior American permission. Even spare parts need to be sourced only from the United States.
.
These 'cradle-to-grave' restrictions arm Washington with continuing leverage over the recipient country. After all, any equipment or system needs maintenance. Such leverage, in turn, can help ensure that the recipient country cooperates with Washington on larger political matters.
.
..... For example, Navy chief Admiral Suresh Mehta had publicly described EUMA as 'intrusive.' Speaking at an April 2008 conference organised by the London-based International Strategic Studies Institute in New Delhi, Admiral Mehta said: 'There are certain things we can't agree to. As a sovereign nation, we can't accept intrusiveness into our system, so there is some fundamental difficulty.'
.
He added: 'The US may have this kind of (end user) agreements with everyone. I don't believe in that. We pay for something and we get some technology. What I do with it, is my thing.'

In fact, India's Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) in a March 2008 report criticized the end-use monitoring clauses in the contract for the USS Trenton/INS Jalashwa. (No sooner the US had transferred that transport ship to India than a gas leak killed an Indian officer and five sailors on board.) ....
.
pls read whole article ...