Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
Why RTR-president-procedure in Venezuela didnt convert Venezuela as low-corrupt as USA?
.
(1) RTR-president procedure does NOT use positive recall but uses negative recall. So many voters dont call for recall, because they fear "what if new person is worse"? The recall procedure I have proposed are positive recall i.e. a voter can approve upto 5 candidates and also approve existing PM. Also, later, the approval is replaced by marks-cum-approval i.e. voter can either approve/ignore or give marks between -100 to 100 to candidates (ignore = zero marks),.
.
(2) Recall procedure in Venezuela is further weakened by condition that at least 190,000 signatures have to be gathered first. (Venezuela has about 1.90 crore voters) Then there is a long process of signature verification. So many times group-A will gather 100,000 signarure , group-B will gather one lakh signature, but supporters of A wont sign on B's petitions etc. Also, many times signature gatherer gets bribed or pressurized. In recall process I have proposed, there is NO signature gathering and so no verification is needed. Each voter has to personally appear at Patwari office or vote via secure APP/SMS, and so verification is done right at the time of approval filing. And there is no possibility of groupism or possibility that some intermediate activists / leaders will sell out
.
(2a) This is called as SYNCHRONOUS RECALL PROCEDURE vs ASYNCHRONOUS RECALL PROCEDURE . In SYNCHRONOUS procedure, several voters must act TOGETHER to go to next level. Whereas in ASYNCHRONOUS procedure, each voters works at his own time on day of his choice, and when certain number is accumulated, change may happen. SYNCHRONOUS procedures are good in small electronics parts, where each component has to do only specific tasks, and each component is connected with others. But some voters may be free on monday, others may be free on tuesday, and so dealing with crores of voters, ASYNCHRONOUS procedures are better. eg Election is synchronous i.e. all voters must vote on same day. But recall procedures we have proposed are NOT synchronous --- any voter can file approval anyday he is free.
.
(3) Next, in Venezuela, Election Council, equivalent to our Election Commission can suspend / cancel recall procedure !!! The Election Council can even suspend signature gathering !!! This makes RTR more cumbersome
.
(4) And finally, Venezuela has RTR over Nation's President, but has no Jury System, no RTR/elections for police chiefs, district education officers, district judges, district public prosecutors etc. And Venezuela has no district level referendum system, and has only national level referendum procedure.
.
So while RTR did help voters in controlling President (eg President was forced to cancel NoteBandi i.e. Demonetization). But it doesnt help voters in ensuring proper policy making, because at PM level, only choices are large political groups, and all large political groups are dependent on paidmedia, and so paidmedia sponsors dictate their policies
.
Due to absence of Jury System, the manufacturers in Venezuela suffer heavy handedness and corruption of officers. And so industrial growth in Venezuela is poor. And so unemployment is high and so is crime
.
Next problem is -- lack of MRCM type law. The crude oil income does DIRECTLY go to commons - it goes to Apex Officers. They all pocket it and waste away. The lack of MRCM is because activists in Venezuela either dont know about MRCM-like-options or they arent interested in reducing poverty and only want to reduce corruption.
.
USA doesnt have MRCM. But USA has JurySys and Recall/Elections at District levels. And so manufacturers face less harassment, and so industrial productivity is high and unemployment is low. So despite no MRCM, USA has low poverty.
.
And due to absence of RTR District Education Officer in Venezuela, education is poor, and so maths/science/engineering education is poor. So again, industry growth is low.
.
----
.
Some FAKE RECALLISTS claim that Venezuela could NOT become USA like country because it doesnt have clauses like "officers must make a good govt website and put all info on govt websites" !! This is nonsense.
.
The RTR in Venezuela could NOT make Veneuela into USA because Venezuela doesnt have RTR at District levels, and doesnt have JurySys. Voters in Venezuela KNOW that officers at rank and file are corrupt, and they dont need a website to know more details. They dont have power to fix the system. And they dont have information about which law-drafts can bring JurySys , recall at district levels and also improve their RTR-President-procedures.
.
For that matter, many political party workers claim that "RTR in Venezuela failed because voters dont have good moral values". So FIRST, we should improve moral values in all voters and ONLY then we should bring RTR !!
.
IOW, "good websites must come next day after recall procedures are printed" , "moral values must come before recall procedures are printed" are all timewaste arguments. .
.
RTR-PM is needed to ensure that powerful person like PM wont dare to cancel Jury/RTR at national. state, district levels and wont dare to cancel MRCM like laws. But change in one one dept comes when national/state/district level Minister?IAS at national/state/district level works , and when private people's work is NOT stalled by them. This needs RTR in several Ministries/dept at National/State/District levels and JurySys at all levels, Claims like "good website" and "moral values" will improve RTR are timewaste arguments put by anti-recallists and pseudo-recallists.
.
So we were to suggestion solution to Venezuela people, we would tell them "use positive recall, use MRCM, use Jury/Recall at all levels". While FAKE RECALLISTS will tell them "add good website clause" !! And anti-recallists will say "print Lokpal law, improve moral values". You can compare and contract the suggestions, and decide who are real and who are fakes.
.
-----------
.
So what do we at RRG learn from Venezuela ? NOTHING NEW !!
.
We at Right to Recall Group already know that negative recall procedure is useless. In fact, there is NOT negative recall in any procedures I have proposed. And we also know that recall procedure should ASYNCHRONOUS i.e. voter should be allowed to file his approvals on anyday a condition like all voters must show up on one day is poor. And thats why except RTR Police Commissioner, RTR-MP and RTR-MLA, all recalls procedures I have proposed are ASYNCHRONOUS,,. And even RTR-PoliceChief has one asynchronous version and first half of RtrMp/RtrMla is asynchronous . The second half of RtrMp/RtrMla is synchronous ONLY because compatibility with existing election laws is needed.
.
So from law-draft point of view, Venezuela recall only tells us what we knew. But from activism point of view, we see that how FAKE RECALLISTS and anti-recallists can use inefficiencies in negative recall to peddle their FAKE claims that "moral values are needed etc", "good websites are needed first" etc etc. Thats NOT knew. Given a crisis, many will come to propose REAL solution and many will come and propose FAKE solutions. ....