Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
(Q) why didnt British simply executed Rashtrapita Bose under any cooked up charge? or sent him to Andman Nicobar prison under cooked up charges. or just murdered him.
.
British had imprisoned Rashtrapita Subhashchandra Bose, and British knew that Rashtrapita Bose is working to escape out of India and work with Russians (Thats why British had refused to let Rasjtrapita Bose travel to China, because they had got information that Rastrapita Bose would try to visit Russia after he lands in China)
.
All in all, British knew that Rastrapita Bose may do a huge damage to British Empire
.
Then why didnt British simply executed Rashtrapita Bose under any cooked up charge?
.
----
.
Added later --- my answer
.
We all can only guess. And my guess -- decision and action of certain communist / leftist activist such as Mahatma Bhagat Singh and Mahatma Chandrashekhar Azad to execute Police Superintendent Sanders played important role in convincing viceroy NOT to murder Rashtrapita Subhashchandra Bose
.
Murdering a leader or executing him in false cases or imprisoning him forever using fake cases was trivially easy for British Viceroys, But the consequences were not always easy to manage. Long before Rashtrapita Bose, Lala Lajpat Rai was opposing Gohkale's psuedo-non-violence plan and was promoting what became known as "garam dal" or strong action again British. So viceroy murdered him, by asking Police Superintendent Sanders and DySP Scott to throw 10s of lathies on Lala Lajpat Rai in broad day light in public Immidiately, British started funding congress leaders , rss-leaders and cpi-leaders to ask activists to put up and NOT to take revenge. All these paid-leaders of congress/rss/cpi started aking activists to "focus" on "other important" tasks and NOT talk about revenge. But these British-paid leaders could NOT convince some communist / leftist activists such as Mahatma Bhagat Singh and Mahatma Chandrashekhar Azad to focus on charities, morning walks at shakha etc . So these activists executed Police SP Sanders. And that was not all -- Mahatma Chandrashekhar Azad was also successful in putting bomb on railway track just before that railway was carrying viceroy. The train passed some one minute earlier, and so viceroy escaped death. But viceroy knew that he cant be lucky again and again and again.
.
And in a similar case, Mahatma Udham Singh travelled all the way to London, and executed Governor Dwyer for Jaliavala Bagh massacare.
.
So British got the hint that they can fire on people and can also murder leaders, and can also fool most activists by paying congress/rss/cpi leaders. But they cant fool ALL activists. Some activists will become "Udham Singh" and strike back.For every Lala Lajpat Rai they murder, they will have to spend huge money to pay congress/rss/cpi leaders to misguide activists and even then some TRUE activists like Mahatma Bhagat Singh , Mahatma Udham Singh etc will become Udham Singh and strike back.
.
And if too many activists become Udham Singh, then costs of maintaining British officers will increase.. For every 10-20 British shot, the British will have to increase salaries for ALL British officers by at least 1%.
.
So British decided to checkmate Subhash without using outright murder as stroke. They increased funding of congress/rss/cpi workers so that Subhashchandra Bose would get LESSER number of activists, and imprisoned him. But his health worsened, and British saw that if Rashtrapita Bose dies in prison, then activists may take that as murder, And so British house arrested him. House arrest gives some freedom to manuever and Rashtrapita Bose used that freedom to escape out of India, and form an army. Rest is all public knowledge.
.
So coming back to question ---- why didnt British murder Rashtrapita Bose the way British murdered Lala Lajpat Rai?
.
My abswer is : Mahatma Bhagat Singh "convinced" British not to murder Rashtrapita Subhashchandra Bose !!
..
My answer also answers a question congress/rss/cpi activists put. Congress/rss/aap=cpi activists often say that "see, one should organize and not act, and see Bhagat Singh acted and all his actions went in vain",. Well, imo, Mahatma Bhagat Singh's action did NOT go invain. In fact, his action played VERY important role in arrival of freedom. It was action of Mahatma Chandrashekhar Azad and Mahatma Bhagat Singh etc which "convinced" British not to murder Rashtrapita Bose they way British had murdered Lala Lajpat Rai. And this enabled Rashptrapita Bose to deliver freedom to India !!
.
Another conclusion is --- if Mahatma Bhagat Singh had joined congress/rss/cpi and NOT did what he did, then British would have thought "see, we murdered Lala Lajpat Rai and nothing happened .. ... so lets murder a few more inconvinent leaders" !!! And result would have been ---- chances that they would have murdered Rashtrapita Bose would have increased !!
.
So all in all, finally, the freedom comes due to activists who cant be fooled by their leaders !! Nothing comes from activists who get fooled by leaders.
.
So imo, most important contribution of Mahatma Chandrashekhar Azad and Mahatma Bhagat Singh was --- he convinced British NOT to murder Rashtrapita Subhashchandra Bose, they way British had murdered Lala Lajpat Rai.