Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

GST flip flops
.
(1) RCM = "reverse charge mechanism" suspended till some date --- so now many with GST numbers will apply for cancellation of GST number !!! Because if they have GST, then they have to pay GST and charge it to customers. But they can call themselves and registered, and use family members' names and eben employees' names , so that revenue per person is below Rs 20 lakhs !!! Their clients will find such "registered sellers'" goods and their services 20% cheaper !! So we will see a "GST number cancellation spree" now. And then all will run again for GST registration when RCM become re-effective
.
(2) Without eWay bill, GST will collapse !! People will simply create END TO END "no bill no gst 20% cheaper" chains !!! eWay bills (and checkposts to check eway bills) were specifically created to stop such end to end top to bottom "no bill no gst 20% cheaper" chains. So if eway bills are kept, then small / medium sellers collapse. And if eway bills are removed, then GST collapses !! The best part about eWay bill is --- they have to be filed over internet !! And at drop of hat, when there are riots or demonstrations, Govt suspends internet, sms and even landline internet (so far cell / landlines phones are not suspended). So I wonder how eway bills will be generated when Govt has shut down net !!!
.
(3) Quarterly return will enable "Missing Trader Fraudsters" i.e. "sellers , who collect GST from buyers and dont deposit with govt", to dupe more clients , as now they have 90 days to 120 days to 180 days window to cheat and buyers wont even know. And if returns are made monthly, then small / medium sellers collapse due to compliance burden.
.
So I request pro-GST folks to print the solutions to GST mess they propose. I wont and shud not bother myself with solving this mess. Because I have proposed that GST is beyond repair since year 2007 (yes, 2007 when VAT was prpposed !!). And I had proposed that wealth tax on land is far far better i.e less bad way to collect taxes. But pro-GST were all ga ga over GST. (And all parties such as congress / rss / aap have supported GST). So pls propose WRITTEN LAW DRAFTS now to deal with GST mess.
.
----
.
Also, many are "praising" Jetleyji for GST "achievements".
.
It is time that Modiji and ONLY Modiji is "praised" for all things we see in this "good and simple tax". It is sad to see that people "praise" some clerk in Ministry or Dept and dont give "credit" to Modiji for GST's "monumental" "achievements".
.
So pls "praise" Modiji ONLY for all GST "achievements"
.
And yes, as such, SoGa / ArKe too can be praised, as both had supported GST. But final credit should go to Modiji, because finally, it was his decision to use GST and not wealth tax.