Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

Opinions about the SURGICAL TRIKE - based on incomplete information, each activist/voter will need to form an opinion on whether
.
(1) US approval - did NaMo actually take prior approval of US Govt to give ahead to the strike, If yes, then why?
.
(2) killcount - did surgical strike kill over 70 terrorists or between 30 and 70 or between 10 and 30 or just below 10
.
(3) satellite , thermal image camera and sniffer dogs - how did our soldiers evade satellite supervision of USA \ China? And how did our soldiers evade sniffer dogs at terrorists launch pads and their thermal image cameras? (PS : I am not sure if thermal image camera will be so effective)
.
(4) past strikes - how many such cross border strikes happened in between 2004 to 2014 and how many kills did those strikes achieved?.
.
(5) publicizing video --- whatever NaMo decides on release of video, I would support that decision. I have no demand etc on this issue. But I dont label those who ask for video as traitor and dont believe in bullying them to silence.
.
The opinions based on incomplete information will play important roles in making many many more opinions
.
-------------
.
Now NaMo-andhbhagats are giving simpleton answers --- (a) NO, NaMo did not take USG approval (2) surgical strike killed over 70 (3) satellite and sniffer dogs - stop asking such questions or I will label you as a traitor (4) zero - MMS was wimp and so no such cross border strikes happened between 2004 to 2014 (5) all those who ask for video are traitors
.
Their underlying answer is --- accept our answer and dont ask uncomfortable questions about US dominance and dont ask uncomfortable questions about satellites and sniffer dogs. OR else, we will label you all question askers as traitors !!!
.
These threats of NaMo-andhbhagats are similar to the threats Janlokpal-andhbhagats, Anna-andhbhagats and ChhoteAnna(*)-andhbhagats gave between 4-apr-2011 till around july-2012. (back then ArKe had aliased himself as ChhoteAnna, and later ArKe aliased himself to Mahatma Arvind Gandhi). The Anna-andhbhagats used to threaten us as "dont you ask questions like 'what if Janlokpal becomes MNC/Missionary agent' or else we will label as you pro-corruption and congress-agent and bjp-agent etc etc". After all, back then all experts and all paidmediamen has unanimously agreed that Janlokpal will never become corrupt and Janlokpal will reduce corruption across administration, police and courts". And only question was kept pending --- whether "PM should come under ambit of Janlokpal or not" !! Essentially, the threats of Janlokpal-andhbhagats and threats of NaMo-andhbhagats are similar.
.
I would request all activists to ignore threats of these e-bullies. And use google and brains to decide the 5 questions
.
And your opinions to these questions will have huge impact on your opinions on several other questions, and what political actions you should take in future. And one's opinion is the reality, rest of the world is an illusion.
.
--------------
.
(1) did NaMo take, and had to take, prior approval of US Govt to give ahead to the strike, If yes, then what factors forced him to take US permission?
.
My opinion is - YES. NaMo had taken prior approval of USA, and thats why operation got delayed. Because USA took some time to give approval and may have put condition like higher price for Rafel fighter planes. And approval was necessary because CIA has too many agents in all key agencies of India and USA has powerful satellite supervision over LoC. And so our soldiers can be easily located by CIA's satellites aided by initial information from CIA's human agents.. And so if CIA alerts Pakistani soldiers and also gives them exact locations of our soldiers, then our soldiers would face serious problem.
.
So dominance of USA forced NaMo to take prior approval of USA. And ditto in case of MMS. MMS too used to take approval of USA on all key issues.
.
Now if your opinion on this question is YES, then your opinion will have effect on your opinions on many other important issues. Why is NaMo not informing voters that he took and had to take prior approval of USG? Heck, why are ArGandhi and MMS also silent on the question that NaMo had to take prior US approval? Why are NaMo-andhbhagats unanimously suppressing this question, by bullying by statements like "all those who ask this question are traitors"? Why is paid-Arnab-paid-Goswami ignoring this question?
.
paid-ToI did gave a small hint towards the fact that NaMo had to taken US approval. On 30-sep, paid-Economic-Times wrote that "USA as kept in loop" . paid-EcoTimes reported that around 9 am 28-sep, i.e. some 12 hours to 18 hours before operation started on 29-sep- 12.30 am, Ajit Doval had phonetalk with Susan Rice. But this news was reported in corner , so that later paidmediamen can say "see, we did inform you". But this phonecall was NOT widely reported by paidnewspapers and not at all reported by paidtvchannels. And paid-EcoTimes didnt say if approval was taken. The words "USA was kept in loop" does clearly say that.
.
Now, I would request reader to reach that paid-EcoTimes' news twice and then disregard it. Paidmediamen will never give information on serious issued like US dominance over SoMoKe. So all in all, each activist / voter needs to decide on his own --- Was NaMo forced to take prior US approval? And if yes, why are SoGa / ArGandhi hiding this fact? And why are NaMo-andbhagats shying away from this question? And threatening to label anyone who raised this question as a traitor?
.
-----------------
.
(2) did surgical strike kill over 70 terrorists or between 30 and 70 or between 10 and 30 or just below 10
.
This question has some importance. Because if strike killed less than 20, then no revenge is served and paidmedia is vastly exaggerating it. And once needs to decid eon who all are paying paidmediamen to exaggerate it.
.
-------------
.
(3) how did our soldiers evade satellite supervision of USA \ China and how did our soldiers evade sniffer dogs at terrorists launch pads ? And how come their thermal image based camera didnt see our soldiers coming? (PS : I have zero information about thermal images)
.
Each person has to decide on his own. My take is - China didnt know and CIA knew all details and was watching whole operation, but didnt tell pakistan. And I cant understand why terrorists didnt put sniffer dogs, night vision camera, thermal image camera and monitorining drones over their launch pads.
.
The satellites need some human input about approximate time and approximate location, and only after that human operator using satellite images can get exact location on the person on ground. China has poor network of human agents in Indian administration --- mostly it is USA and leftover of Russia. And China doesnt have very many satellites, Or may be, China was threatened with banning of Chinese goods.
.
To closely monitor LoC's specific positions, satellites have to be positioned in some specific zone in space over LoC. So. China can be asked to keep its satellites away from those specific zones in space in return for some deals. But USA can be bought or forced with such small offers. So huge costs was paid to buy silence of USA during these operations.
.
The cost has been known since ages, In 1999, during Kargil war, ABV agreed to allow FDI in insurance , media and agreed to pass patent bill , to convince USA to stop helping Pakistan. And also to convince USA to let France / Russia give us laser guided bombs. Without that, war would have lasted for several more months, and our casulties would have crossed several thousand, and in such case ABV would have lost the coming elections. Same can be deal here --- allow FDI in all areas (i.e. handover all sectors of Indian economy one by one via FDI) and USA will assist India in cross border terrorism by not giving satellite based information to Pakistan.
.
Use of Military for trade / investment isnt new. It has been there since 10000 years. Some recent known and best documented examples is are "gunboat diplomacy under Mathew Perry" in 1850s. In 1850s, USA's Navy Chief Mathew Perry took some 5 to 10 large gunboats with huge cannons to Japan and asked for "permission" to trade inside Japan, and allow Missionaries and also allow US merchant ships to use Japanese ports. The cannons were so powerful, that US ships can damage Japanese port from a distance. That distance would be large enough that Japenese cannons mounted on Japanese shore wont be able to harm the US ships. And if Japan sends any ship to destroy those US ships, then that Japanese ship will get destroyed before it comes close enough that it can do any damage to the US ship. And Japanese saw that even if Japanese had managed to destroy those 5 - 10 US warships, the damage on ports will be huge and 100 more US warships would come. And US warships can destroy all Japanese merchant ships anywhere in world. So Japanese in 1850s allowed USA to trade in Japan and also allowed Missionaries,
.
Pakistan is a huge gunboat for hire against India. And USA has very effectively used this Pakistan to blackmail all PMs from Devi Indira Amma to NaMo, no exceptions. The blackmail is so sound that NO PM ever had courage to even inform his activists and voters of India about this blackmail. "Military assisted FDI via proxy-gunboats " has been very effective.
.
As per sniffer dogs, thermal camera, night vision camera of terrorists and monitoring drones to stop intruders, I think may be terrorists didnt have them. So basically, there were some very very low value terrorists. Or many, very few terrorists were there.
.
NaMo-andhbhagats want to tell us all that USA's satellites did not have any clue about this surgical strike. And worse, anyone who asks questions on satellite etc is a fool and a traitor !!! I request you to disregard their e-threats and worry only if they decide to use physical means. But pls do gather information on ability of satellites, ability of sniffer dogs , drone based monitoring, thermal images with camera etc. Information on such things can be useful.
.
-------------
.
(4) past strikes - how many such cross border strikes happened in between 2004 to 2014 and how many kills did those strikes achieved?.
.
When Obama killed Osama bin Laden, he didnt beat drums that "see, I can do something that no republican do". But here, we are seeing high decibel drum beating. Rajiv Gandhi too had done a good job in finishing Punjab terrorism, but he didnt make this a point in election campaigns in India.
..
But NaMo and NaMo-andhbhagats are putting posters in UP, which effectively mean that "vote for BJP MLA candidates because NaMo is the ONLY one who did cross border operations of this scale in past 20 years" !!! So the question of past strikes become relevant.
.
So we need some summary statistical information, not details, right from Military on how many strikes were done between 2004 and 2014 and what ere their killcounts.
.
---------
.
(5) Video of surgical strike
.
I see no need. And if Military feels that video should not be released, then they should not be released
.
---
.
So all in all, pls form opinions on above based on whatever incomlete information you can get.