Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

A. Some asked VALID LOOKING FAKE question -- "Jury System , DDMRCAM, RTR, wealth tax, TCP etc will take time till weapons are made --- and so what should we do TODAY ?!!" . Well, FDI will also take years --- weapons wont come tomorrow. Let me give details.
.
B. FDI in weapons will NOT reduce costs as weapons is monopoly business. The costs will come ONLY if manufacturers are 100% Indians
.
C. FDI may create some jobs. But when companies ask for repatriation of profits, the economy will contract and that will create a bigger loss of jobs on future.
.
D. Israel of population of 80 lakhs and USA of population 32 crore can make 50 times more weapons than they need,. But BST-workers say that we MUST allow foreigners to make weapons.
=========================.
A.
Most BST-workers and most RSS-workers now support MNC-owners' demand that India should allow MNC-owners to setup weapon making factories. The goal of MNC-owners is to ensure that 100% Indian weapon making factories dont grow.
.
Now problem is also real --- India is importing all weapons and not making any weapons. BST-workers in past 6 years did NOT give any newspaper advertisement to highlight this problem and its solution. They confined to tel-sabun swadeshi , slogan shouting, rallying, member making etc etc. They opposed the solutions like Jury System, DDMRCAM, Wealth tax, inheritance tax, RTR, TCP etc. BST-workers spent 6 years in timepass and RSS-workers spent 95 years in timepass or say 20 years in timepass. Now they scream emergency and want to impose FDI in defence using emerency cries.
.
Well lets see how law-drafts such as TCP, DDMRCAM etc imrpove situation.
.
1. DDMRCAM will give mineral royalty DIRECTLY into citizens' account. So within 1 week, citizens will see the value of natural resources and why they must remain in India for their well being and well being of their children. DDMRCAM will make every citizen ACTUALLY feel that he is the owner of the country and will make country and its land worth living and dying for,
.
2. Jury System, wealth tax etc if it comes today, will improve gun manufacturing within 2-3 months. And within 1 year, every Indian will have 2-3 guns and 100s of bullets and that will be sufficient to ensure that no country can move deep inside India.
.
3. Next, within few months to at most 2 years, it will improve technology to make drones and short\medium range missiles. With Jury System ,
.
4. Within few months we can make underground shelters for whole country , which will reduce the damage air raids of China or Pakistan can do on India.
.
So within 3 years we will have sufficient number of missiles to hit back. That will be sufficient to deter China from waging war against India.
.
And FDI is not going to make weapons in few weeks or even few years. The US or Japanese companies will either ask for very high prices or negotiations will take weeks. After that, they will bring assembly lines and their own technicians. And then they will start manufacturing. And when war starts. they will ask for 10 times the prices anyway. In fact, when war with China starts. the US companies would first let India suffer as much damage as possible, and only when we are completely ruined, they will provide weapons just enough to survive back. So that weakened Indian can be taken over with ease.
.
So Jurysys, TCP, DDMRCAM, wealth tax etc will improve manufacturing abilitiy at fast rate. While FDI does NOTgive us any skills at except screw driver assemblies.
.
===========
.
B.
FDI brings down cost of production but NOT the final sale prices. Why? Because weapons are monopoly items, And so price doesnt depend on cost. In monopoly, the item's manufacturing price can be as low as Rs 10, but monopoly owner may sell it for as high as Rs 100. So if a US company makes weapons in India, then cost will be cheaper, but then also US company will keep same high price as it has monopoly. Also, when war starts, it will increases prices by 10 times --- something an Indian company will not be able to do to that extent. So solution is to reduce infficiencies of local manufacturer using JurySys, wealth tax etc and not fall at US companies feet and beg them to make factiries in India.
.
==============
.
C.
FDI may create some jobs. But not many, as in weapons business, most jobs are design and manufacturing is mostly automated and doesnt need many workers. Also, when companies ask for repatriation of profits in dollars, the value of rupee will fall, petrol prices will increase and so the local economy will contract. And that will create a bigger loss of jobs on future. IOW, for every job FDI creates, "repatriation trap" similar to "debt trap" will reduce more jobs.
.
Its similar to debt. When debt is taken, one can create jobs using debt. But when time comes to repay debt plus interest, the failure to repay can shut down the business and create job loss. In case of FDI, debt trap is replaced by repatriation trap, which is worse than debt trap.
.
====
D.
Finally, israel of population 80 lakhs can make weapons, but we cant !!! Why not? Because of nonsensical laws we have. And what did RSS-workers and BST-workers and AAP-workers to fix these laws? NOTHING. They did NOT even inform citizens on what laws can fix things in India. They just confined to slogan shouting, mask wearing, cap wearing, neta-puja etc etc. And now when China, pakistan etc enemies have come to the door, they shout emeregency and want Americans and Japanese to help !! Well folks, let RSS-workers and BST-workers shourt "FDI zindabaad" as much as they want. I request you all to focus on law-drafts which can create TRUE growth without FDI and true LOCAL weapon manufacturing.
.

.