Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
Alt News:
‘Where did our votes go?’: Ask electors in Bengal’s New Town where BJP polled 97% votes in a Muslim majority booth
In Booth 164 of West Bengal’s Rajarhat New Town, the assembly election result has sparked questions among local residents, opposition leaders and political workers. When Alt News visited the constituency and spoke to voters, several of them described the result as absurd and impossible.
The CPI(M)-ISF alliance candidate Saptarshi Deb received just one vote from Booth 164. #TMC candidate Tapash Chatterjee secured five votes, while BJP candidate Piyush Kanodia, who won the seat, got 637 of the 656 votes polled.
Booths 164 and 165 are located in a locality known as Musalman Para, a predominantly #Muslim neighbourhood. In the neighbouring Booth 165, which draws voters from the same locality and, in many cases, even from the same families, Kanodia received 32 votes, compared to Deb’s 299 and Chatterjee’s 290. In sharp contrast, in 164, where 88% of the electors are Muslims, BJP polled 97% of the votes.
Locals told #AltNews that the result of Booth 164 was difficult to reconcile with the area’s political and demographic profile.
The results for #NewTown were declared on May 5, a day after the rest of West Bengal’s election results.
The results were mired in controversy from the very beginning as the seat underwent 18 rounds of counting instead of the pre-notified 17 rounds. There were a total of 330 polling stations in the constituency, including 10 auxiliary booths. Each counting round was supposed to consist of the tallying of 20 EVMs. Accordingly, candidates expected 17 rounds of counting — 16 rounds involving 20 EVMs each and a final round involving the remaining 10 EVMs.
Why did the need for an extra round of counting arise?
The 18th round can be linked to 52 additional votes being recorded on the EVM at Booth 164 on the polling day. There, voting was suspended for nearly two hours after polling agents noticed that the EVM displayed 52 more votes than had actually been cast.
A polling agent told Alt News that although the #EVM showed zero votes after mock poll (conducted before voting began), it was unclear whether the VVPAT slips for the mock votes had been removed. The agents from multiple political parties jointly submitted a written request seeking a #VVPAT count for Booth 164. This was Round 18.
Until Round 17 of counting, BJP candidate Piyush Kanodia was trailing TMC’s Tapash Chatterjee. However, the counting of Booth 164 at the very end dramatically altered the outcome.
The 18th and final round (for Booth 164) showed 656 votes. Of these, Kanodia secured 637 votes, Chatterjee received five votes, and Deb received a single vote. The same figures are reflected in Form 20.
In other words, the result of Booth 164 directly determined the outcome of the constituency. At 11 pm on May 4, Chatterjee was leading by 316 votes, with one booth yet to be counted. After the 18th and final round, which covered only Booth 164, the lead reversed entirely, and Kanodia won by 316 votes.
The unusual result was first highlighted by Scroll in a report published on May 21.
When #AltNews visited Musalman Para, local residents expressed bewilderment at the outcome and went on record about whom they had voted for. Among them were CPI(M) panchayat members and active ISF workers. If the final result of Booth 164 is to be believed, they voted en masse for the BJP.
“That is simply not true. Then where did our votes go?” several residents asked.
Locals told Alt News that because of an increase in the number of electors, the original polling station had been divided into two auxiliary booths — Booths 164 and 165. Voters from the same neighbourhood were distributed between the two booths without any obvious pattern. In several instances, even members of the same family found themselves assigned to different booths.
One resident, Ruksana Begum, said she voted at Booth 165 while her 25-year-old son, Sahinur, voted at Booth 164. Alt News encountered several such examples during its visit.
“We cannot fathom how the BJP secured so many votes from our booth. Something certainly appears unusual,” one resident said.
Ahmed Ali Mondol, a two-time elected CPI(M) panchayat member representing the Jagadishpur area, which covers Booths 164 and 165, said that he and eight members of his family had voted at Booth 164 in favour of the CPI(M)-ISF alliance.
“My family members and I all voted from Booth 164 for the alliance candidate. But the results show only one vote from the booth. Where did our votes go?” Mondol asked.
Another local CPI(M) supporter, Ashraf Ali, said the results defied logic, particularly given the stark contrast between two adjacent booths populated by residents of the same locality.
Referring to the official figures, Ali said, “In Booth 165, the CPI(M) was leading by nine votes, whereas in Booth 164, the party received only one vote. I cannot understand how such a difference is possible.”
Ali added that while he voted at Booth 165, his wife voted at Booth 164. Asked whether he was certain that his wife had voted for the CPI(M) candidate, he replied, “Of course. We are CPI(M) supporters.”
“Where did all these votes go?” he wondered. Ali further argued that if the CPI(M)-ISF alliance could secure a lead in Booth 165, then Booth 164 should also have reflected substantial support for the alliance.
“The BJP stood no chance here. The real contest has always been between the CPI(M) and the TMC,” he claimed.
Echoing similar concerns, local resident and ISF leader Akhtar Ali Mollah said that he, along with at least eight members of his family, had voted for the CPI(M)-ISF alliance candidate from Booth 164.
Read the full report by Shinjinee Majumder, Ankita Mahalanobish and Ankit Jain on the Alt News website. Link in comment.
#AltNews #AltNewsFactCheck #altnewsinvestigation #altnewsreport #informationjustice #altnewsanalysis #propaganda #WestBengal #election #RajarhatNewTown #ElectionResults #GroundReporting