Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

Which apex leaders were against giving voting rights to all voters in 1946?
.
---
.
[Rajendra] Prasad was quoted to have said at a public address that the adoption of adult franchise “was causing him and his colleagues grave anxiety...Unless properly exercised, adult franchise was fraught with grave dangers. It would mean putting educated and ignorant and honest and dishonest persons on the same footing.”
.
---
.
Just before the draft constitution was brought for consideration before the Constituent Assembly in November 1948, the Times of India editorial stated:

Certain principles embodied in the draft constitution have been called into question since their adoption by the Constituent Assembly or its committees. One of these is adult franchise. Although the leadership of the Congress is committed to this principle, there is growing evidence of anxiety lest in the present state of the masses’ education the vesting of this powerful political weapon in the entire adult population should lead to abuse of the democratic system.
.
No less than Dr Rajendra Prasad has given expression to hesitancy in this behalf. A similar feeling was voiced in the Madras legislature when that body discussed the draft constitution six months ago. Constitutional pundits ask. “Are we going to be governed by the ignorant, the unwise, ‘the thriftless’?” It may be a trifle late in the day to go back on the principle of universal suffrage, but the Constituent Assembly might profitably consider devices which would minimise the danger of unrestricted political power in the hands of millions not yet sufficiently trained in the art of democratic government.
.
see https://scroll.in/article/870993/as-newly-independent-india-set-about-becoming-a-democracy-the-press-played-a-crucial-role .
.
------------
.
Who had paid Times of India to write an editorial against Right to Vote, in a way that it will appear that he is suipporting it?
.
Also, download pdf at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm/SSRN_ID3734091_code2126198.pdf . Some sentences from this PDF
.
Brajeshwar Prasad found universal adult franchise as a ‘violation of the tenets of democracy. He went on to add: ‘Adult franchise presupposes that the electorate is enlightened. Where the electorate is not enlightened there cannot be parliamentary
democracy.’
.
M. Thirumala Rao was not enthusiastic about it. He noted that by adopting this measure, 17 crore Indians would be empowered to vote. He felt that: “without proper education, without the proper development of patriotism in this country, ...this is a dangerous weapon” Further, he added, only the fringe Indian population comprising of the ‘intelligentsia and the intellectual middle class’ had participated and engaged with the freedom movement. .
.
According to him, only a small category of Indians truly understood and imbibed the value of patriotism- which is unknown to the larger population. As a result, the franchise would largely be motivated by regional and communal lines.
.
KT Shah also felt that literacy is the “minimum of requirement in democratic citizenship”. A nation with more than 85 per cent of its population being illiterate must adopt measures to abolish illiteracy in ten years. Hirday Nath Kunzru conceded that while franchise must not be ....
.
-----------
.
For more, pls download ALL Constituet Assembly quotes. And seach on words like "adult suffrage" , "right to vote". And then there are 100s of statemnents made via editorial
.
Jawaharlal Ghazi or Sardar Vallbhbhai Patel never spoke a word against Univeral Voting. But if no one was against universal voting, then why universal voting was NOT made a fundamental right? If right to religuion or right to speech can be fundamental right, then surely, right to vote, more important that speech or religion, would have become fundamental right.
.
To make long story short, BR Ambedkar was ONLY apex leader fully pushing fully for universal right to vote. Because he knew that if education or property was used as criteria, then not even 1% dalit and not even 5% OBC will get right to vote.
.
And when BRA asked members to support his proposal to make right to vote a fundamental right, BRA could NOT find even 10 members to support it !!!
.
So imo, members of constituient assembly were against univeral voting. They tried they best to sideline this issue. But BRA made it an issue. Once it became an issue, they could not sideline it.
.
As per leaders of RSS / CPI , who were not in constituent assembly lesser said better , on issue of universal voting. CPI only wanted to use the issue to malign congress/rss, but CPI itself was never committed to even "voting". The apex leaders of CPI believed in iron control like Stalin. And RSS leaders back then openly promoted "karna adharit varna vyavastha" . So expecting universal voting from them is pointless.