Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
exposing fake opposition of monarchy supporters
.
The RTR-opposers tried "rtr will bring instability" nonsensem, "janlokpal is far better nonsense", "namo is great , no need for RTR" nonsense and 10s of others nonsenses. But now when they have seem to have run out of nonsenses, and so they are cookking up "monarchy is better solution" nonsense
.
so question is --- how to counter them before audience
.
Today, one problem is that audience of 35 years or younger never saw horrors of monarchy. So "monarchy" like UK can be presented as good society. Next, throw in conspiracy theory that "USA is controlled by UK" to counter that if monarchy is good, then why is USA far ahead of UK !!
.
So how to counter this new fake opposition , namely "monarchists"
.
(01) UK was monarchy, but became strong ONLY after monarch accepted Jury System, i.e. England monarchs in 950 AD to 1200 AD agreed that judges appointed by monarchs will have limited powers can decisions will be given by citizens selected at random from list of all male citizens between age 21 years and 45 years. And this system came becuase Swedish invaders who had taken over England, had this system in Sweden since 700 BC
.
So reason why England became strongest of all monarchies in Europe in 1200 AD, was because England monarch had accepted Jury System in 950 AD onwards in step by step fashion. Later, England also installed system of election of MP. And now, in England District Police Commissioners in all 32 districts except England are elected by voters since year 2012.
.
So UK monachy accepted democratic agecies liek Jury System and election of MPs in years 950 AD onwards. All other monarchies did not accept any democratic modification and weakened.
.
(02) The problem with monarchy is --- succession. The first monarchs are generally good. But monarchs after 3 generations are either bad or mentally less competent or both.
.
(03) Monarchies have tendencies to become INHERITANCE based, and then rot increases. Only monarchy which could PARTIALLY save itself from inheritance was Afghanistan, where monarch was "elected" by a semi democratic body called Loya Jigra, but that monarch will have term of almost whole life
.
(04) So in a two nation COMPARSION, say one nation has monarchy and another has recall / election / jury based system, the second nation will become more and more powerful and then takeover the monarchy. This is what happened starting 1400 AD. England was monarchy, but accepeted JurySystem and election of MPs. And England became more powerful than France. And by 1760 AD, England was so powerful, that it started taking over parts of India. And USA removed monarchy, and installed elected executives, including elected police chiefs and judges, elected legislatures, Jury System, referendum, recall --- it became so powerful that it is engulfing whole world.
.
(05) After making above points before audience, the recallists should ask monarchist to give link to the FB post or PDF which full DRAFT of the how the first monarch should be chosen, and DRAFT of how next monarch should be chosen . The DRAFT must be in written, The so called monarchists in India, have not written a signle DRAFT to decide who should be first monarch of India, and how next monarch should be appointed.
.
(06) if the monarchist doesnt give draft, then followimng point can be made before auduience "see, we recallists have written DRAFT of how we propose to end corruption in PMO CMO etc via RTR PM, RTR CM etc. And imo, ONLY reason why USA is stronger than India, is because USA has this Jurysys, recall etc and we are working to bring same laws in India. Now, monarchists claim that they have better proposal. Well, fine. Then without WRITTEN draft, how can anyone see thru the proposal?"
.
(07) And recallism, is not just recall on PM CM MP MLA . We have proposed laws like RTR police commissioner, Rtr judges, Jury System, Dhanvapasi and over 30 WRITTEN proposals . Can monarchists also enable audience to compare our drafts with their wirtten drafts on how they plan to improve courts, how they plan to improve police and how they plan to fix mineral royalty loot? Or "get good monarch and we dont need any good laws" is the proposal?
.
(08) In year 2014, RSS-workers had floated the proposal "we dont need any good lawdrafts, just get a good PM at top". And we saw notebandhi and GST, and lockdown and forced vax. So now proposal like "lets get a good monarch and no laws are needed is another proposal on same line".
.
(09) and if monarchists do give a written draft , then yes, we need to compare that draft with our drafts. That will be a longer exercise
.
All in all, anti-RTR people have no argument against RTR in present democratic framework. So "lets end democracy and bring monarchy" and "lets end democracy and lets have libertarianism based private police, private military" etc are new timepass they have taken