Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

Constitution art-328 does allow MLAs i.e. State Assembly of a State to end EVMs in that State.
.
But no party ever banned EVM in their state.** This proves that congress, rss, aap, cpm etc are all pro-EVM in reality
.
art-328 says "328. Subject to the provisions of this Constitution and in so far as provision in that behalf is not made by Parliament, the Legislature of a State may from time to time by law make provision with respect to all matters relating to, or in connection with, the elections to the House or either House of the Legislature of the State including the preparation of electoral rolls and all other matters necessary for securing the due constitution of such House or Houses."
.
"इस संविधान के उपबंधों के अधीन रहते हुए और जहां तक संसद् इस निमित्त उपबंध नहीं करती है वहां तक, किसी राज्य का विधान-मंडल समय-समय पर, विधि द्वारा, उस राज्य के विधान-मंडल के सदन या प्रत्येक सदन के लिए निर्वाचनों से संबंधित या संसक्त सभी विषयों के संबंध में, जिनके अंतर्गत निर्वाचक-नामावली तैयार कराना और ऐसे सदन या सदनों का सम्यक् गठन सुनिाश्चित करने के लिए अन्य सभी आवश्यक विषय हैं, उपबंध कर सकेगा ।"
.
The art-328 doesnt NOT give full control over state election to MLAs. But It says that MLAs can make laws about State Assembly elections, and they should NOT be against laws made by Parliament.
.
Now Partliament has NOT made EVM compulsory, It has only give OPTION to ECI to use EVMs. To be specific, ONLY clause in Representation of People Act 1951, which talks about EVM says
.
clause-61A. Voting machines at elections.—Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or the rules made thereunder, the giving and recording of votes by voting machines in such manner as may be prescribed, may be adopted in such constituency or constituencies as the Election Commission may, having regard to the circumstances of each case, specify
.
IOW, it used word "may". So Parliament does NOT make EVM uses binding. The words "may use EVM" here means "may use EVM" or "need not use EVM".
.
Hence, if Assembly directs by making law to ECI. that ECI shall i.e. MUST use paper ballot and not use EVMs, then Assembly isnt contradicting any order of Parliament. And art-328 makes Parliament as first agency to make election rules, and makes State Assembly as second agency to make rules, and ECI is third agency to make rules neded to implement the rules made by Parliament and State Assembly.
.
So State Assembly can make laws to end EVM in that State.
.
And State Assembly can also make rules to endure that ECI doesnt use black glass and must use transparent glass in EVM.
.
And if State Assembly makes the law, then ECI will have to end use of EVMs in that State or take the matter to Supreme Court.
.
But fact is --- congress , aap , CPM , TRS, DMK, TMC etc who have majority in some State Assemblies, never printed law for EvmHatao in their states !!! Even if ECI denies or takes matter to Supreme Court, thee would have been political mileage,. AAP could have brought bill to end EVMs in Delhi State Assembly election using art-328 of constitution. And AAP has sizeable precense in Punjab / Goa assembly to bring private member EvmHatao bill in those two states. But AAP didnt bring any private member bills either.
.
IOW, unusing of art-328 proves that in reality, congress / rss / aap / TCM / CPM etc are all pro EVM only.
.
If you want to comment, use this post -- https://www.facebook.com/groups/MehtaRahulC/posts/665682427928619/