Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

As per amended Mauritius treaty, as amended by NaMo in year 2016, usuk-apex-elitemen defacto pay 0% to at most only 7.5% income tax in India . And how is this related to farmer agitation?
.
RSS-workers had unleashed a propaganda that loopholes in mauritius treaty have been closed. That was , as always, a lie.
.
Pls see my may-2016 post on this for details
.
https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10153479816646922
.
And how is this related to farmer agitation?
.
Because agents of usuk-elitemen namely ta bir baj am ad are funded by usuk-elitemen. These usuk-elitemen defacto pay only 0% to atmost only 7.5% income tax. While aadatiya ( = aarhaatiya = agents who buy from farmers and then sell to other traders ) and other selffunded Indian grain traders have to pay income tax of almost 30% to 40% , if income is above Rs 20 lakhs per year !!!
.
So if new farm laws go on, then aadatiya will be out and most Indian non-elitemen-agents will get pushed out of market. And once aadatiya and other traders exit the markets, usuk-agents namely ta bir baj am ad will offer lesser and lesser prices to the farmers. The farmers have smelled the danger coming. And so they are opposing the three farm laws !!!

Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate:

Can a CA explain this "feature" of new amended Mauritius Tax Treaty --- Banks based in Mauritius loaning money in India will pay only 7.5% tax on interest earned.
.
pls see website - http://www.thequint.com/business/2016/05/11/no-india-mauritius-tax-treaty-wont-drive-foreign-investors-away
/.
It says
.
-====
.
3. Source-based taxation of interest income of banks: Interest arising in India to Mauritian resident banks will be subject to withholding tax in India at the rate of 7.5% in respect of debt claims or loans made after 31st March, 2017. However, interest income of Mauritian resident banks in respect of debt-claims existing on or before 31st March, 2017 shall be exempt from tax in India.
.
====
/
So ;lets say a US company-X invests in India by forming subsidiary company-X-India and earns income. Then that income will be taxed at normal 25% rate --- same as Indian company. Equal equal --- no discrimination.
.
But if that company-X first forms a bank-Y in Mauritius, and then bank-Y lends money to company-X-India , and charges such heavy interest that income of company-X-India becomes almost zero and bank-Y earns huge income via interest. Then will effective tax be ONLY 7.5%?
.
If so, then tax rate has only changed from 0% to 7.5% instead of 25%. Is that so?
.
Is so, then super-elitemen, who can form a bank in Mauritius, and also operate in India, will be taxed at 7.5%. Whereas others will be taxed normal rate of 25% to 30%.
.
==============
.
The amended treaty says that short term capital gains will be taxed at 30%. But with this new feature that interest earned by Mauritius banks will be taxed at only 7.5%, the effective tax rate on short term capital gains also becomes 7.5% only !!! How?
.
Say Mauritius-bank-X = X and bank-Y belong to same owner.
.
Say X buys shares of Indian company A and sells it and earns profit of say Rs 100 crore. So short term capital gains tax applies on bank-X. But say bank-X is also owning shares of some Indian company-B which it had bought for say Rs 200 crores. . Now Indian company B can take huge loans at heavy interest rate from bank-X . And so due to debt, shares of B will fall to RS 100 crore. So now bank-X can sell the shares to bank-Y, which belongs to same owner. And it will create short term capital loss of Rs 100 crore to bank-X. And so net capital gains is ZERO. And so net capital gains tax is also zero!!!/
.
IOW, effective tax on USUK bank owners is only 7.5% and not 25% or 30% as NaMo is telling us.
.
=====
.
Can a CA answer this question?