Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

(Q01) Infighting amongst private police companies question
.
Following question Imo convinces neutral audience that libertarianism is just an attractive fake solution created by Rothschilde etc , to ensure that activists are demotivated to work for Jury / Recall / WealthTaxt / DhanVapsi
.
(1) India has 140 crore citizens , and now say India becomes a libertarian society.
.
(2) so there is no monopoly police now. there are many private police companies and anyone can start a new one.
.
(3) Now say there are 100 to 200 private police / court companies.
.
(4) Now say one strong / large private police company decides to rob and destroy a weaker / smaller police company.
.
(5) These two companies have 10 crore citizen clients.
.
Question --- so now what should remaining 130 crore citizens who have no contracts with these two companies do? Should these 130 crore citizens of India side with company which is "right" and force the wrong company to walk away? Or should they remain neutral and let stronger private police company win?
.
This question imo breaks the myth of libertarianism aka total privatization of police / courts !!
.
No book written by libertarian "scholar" addresses the issue on what citizens of society should do if one private police company decide to rob and finish other private police company in the libertarian society !!
.
Thats because libertarianism thought was never created to solve any problem !! Libertarianism was created by scholars hired by usuk-elitemen to promote timepass so that solutions like movement for votevapsi / recall , JuryCourt, Dhanvapasi passbook etc (which breaks the hegomony of usuk-elitemen) can be sabotaged !!! The activists will spend time in libertarian timepass, and will not get time to understand Jury, Recall , Mineral Royalties and other concepts.
.
Pls ask the libertarian to create a album on his profile called libertarianism. And pls ask him to create a post which replaces what 130 citizens should do when one private police company decides to rob a smaller / weaker police company. And in addition, create a group, in which, create a UNIT called a libertarianism, and also post answer to this question.
.
Pls ask them. And pls see their answers
.
============
.
Many libertarians will answer that private police companies will NOT fight in libertarian society
.
Well, before Prophet Mohammad came, Arabia was libertarian society. There was no centralized state or even districrt / l;evel govt. Each tribe had its own police or military or whatever you call. And one tribe's police or military or whatever robbing karavan of other tribe was very common
.
And Prophet Mohammad was able to establish stronger military or police or whatever you may say, and was able to defeat all. Here, his military became stronger than others due to religion. But whatever may be the reason, infighting was indeed there.
.
So private police companies will NEVER fight with another private police company is historically wrong. They may not fight or may fight.
.
If India decides to become libertarian, and dissolves state police, then within weeks there will be 100 private police company. And company which gets funding and weapons from Bill Gates or geaorge Soros or Rothschilde, will be able to defeat and rob all !!! Thats one likely scenario.
.
======================
.
BACKGROUND to private police question
-----------------------
.
Many Libertarians define Libertarianism as --- COMPLETE privatization of police / courts !!! Not just privatization of railways etc (which will be rightist), privatization of banks etc but complete privatization of police / courts !!! And in the libertarian society, there will no PM / CM / MP / MLA etc, And there will ONLY contracts and no laws !!! And there will be no taxes.
.
In libertarian society, there will be multiple private police companies and each individual will be free to form new private police company. And individuals will have contracts with private police company.
.
There will be FEES which individual will have to pay to private police company. But these fees will be much lower than taxes because there will be competing private police companies !!! So libertarian India with no monopoly police will have lesser costs for protecting life and property.
.
Many people call themselves as Libertarians , and are opposed to TOTAL privatization of police courts . Well, pls do ask some "true" libertarians. If you oppose privatization of police courts, then you are NOT libertarian.
.
I dismiss all labels such as rightist , leftists, communist, socialist, capitalist etc as useless labels and always ask activists to decide which LAW DRAFTS they support / oppose. But libertarianism label is exception, because this concept opposes monopoly police !!! All others, be capitalists or communists or rightists or we recallists support citizens' monopoly over police and thus we all believe in TAXES needed to fund this monopoly police, Whereas libertarians believe in ending monopoly over police, and thus ending taxes COMPLETELY !!!
.
So one may ask this "(Q01) Infighting amongst private police companies question" to them, if you find this question is important
.
======================
.
Flawed answer by Libertarian Guru - Robert Murphy
.
Robert Murphy is much praised Guru in Libertarian Thought . This is what he says on "what should citizens do if private police companies fight"
.
Will private police companies fight or not?
.
https://cdn.mises.org/Chaos%20Theory_2.pdf
,
I could find only 2 para in Chaos Theory book
.
page-22
.
Warring Agencies
.
Critics often dismiss private law by alleging that disputes between enforcement agencies would lead to combat—even though this happens between governments all the time! In truth, the incentives for peaceful resolution of disputes would be far greater in market anarchy than the present system. Combat is very expensive, and private companies take much better care of their assets than government officials take care of their subjects’ lives and property.
.
In any event, those engaging in “warfare” in a free society would be treated as any other murderers. Unlike government soldiers, private mercenaries would receive no special privileges to engage in condoned violence.
.
Those agencies interpreting the law would not be the same as the firms enforcing it.
.
There is no intrinsic reason to worry about battles between private enforcement agencies, any more than battles between the government army and navy
.
---------------------
.
Well prophet Mohammad in Saudi Arabia is one exception that proves above theory false. Saudi Arabia in those days was a libertarian society, with each tribe having its own police. Intra tribe wars were common. And Mohammand made better police / military and defeated all. So same is likely to happen if Indian become libertarian society today, Some private poluice funded by Bill Gates or Soros or Rothschilde will takeovberm because they will have far better weapons
.
----------
.
Also, author assumes that private company police and private court company will be different,. They can be same
.
----
,.
And these two statements are false --- "There is no intrinsic reason to worry about battles between private enforcement agencies, any more than battles between the government army and navy"
.
Two private police companies fighting is core problem in libertarian theory and will come in practice too. And comparsion wioth army and navy is flawed. The soldiers answer DIRECTLY to PM and would lose jobs and pension if they violate orders of PM. So if there is dispute bnetween army and navy, then PM will decide, and both will obey. So he answers "what will happen is two private police companies will fighht" using a FLAWED analofgy !!!
.
-----
.
And finally, hedidnt answer what should citizens do if two private police company decide to fight? He evaded the question by saying --- this wont happen.
.
We recallists dont evade such question. In cas, two units of Army decide to fight, then citizens using majority vote shoukld decvide who is right and suppress the other party. And yes, sometimes ciovila way come. But in nation where majority vote, recall and Jury are there, the citizens adopt some solution, that may not be acceptable to all, but averts a civil war
.
But when police companies are private, the fight\s are likely (eg Saudi Arabia case)