Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

health card --- minus point -- govt officers will know about all diseases / medicines person took, and may misuse the data by legally illegally giving it to Indian / Foreigner medicine mafia. But what are PLUS points?
.
post 014 , A043.014
.
problem is lockdown, and many activists , who only want chatpati suspense conspiracy theories , and have no interesting in reducing poverty or poor or reducing inefficiencies of factory owners, simply take whatever issue that is highlighted by lockdown-agents like Vishvaroop Roy Gandhi, David Icke etc etc And the health card issue will be used to these chatpati-suspense-CT-loving people.
.
health card is same as addhar number added to all treatments. But instead of adhar, a new ID was created, so that patient doesnt need to disclose his aadhar to doctor
.
plus points of health card ---
.
(1) It is now impossible to run health subisidies without this card i.e. this card VASTLY reduces FALSE govt health expenditure and may also reduce false expenses that patients have to pay. How will false govt expenditure reduce.?
.
Say a Govt subsidized hospital reports that it was was giving 30 tablets per month to say 10000 patients, and collects money for 300,000 tablets from Govt, Today, hospital puts any 10000 names. And that hospital may be giving tablets to only 5000 patients or even less. But with health ID-card, hospital has to give health card numbers of patients. So say a person didnt get those 30 tablets and he is put in the list,. Then that person will see in his mobile app linked with health ID card number that 30 tablets were issued in his name !!! And so some patients may complaint. So hospitals' ability to report ungiven treatment reduces. So govt's FALSE expenses will fall.
.
(2) say a hospital treated 5000 patient who all needed some bandage,. Noe bandage comes in roll of 10 meters. Its possible that hospital bought only 2500 bandages because each patient needs only 5 meters of bandage. And hospital charged one bandage cost to ALL 5000 patients !!! With health card, ALL data comes to one place. And so such theft can be easily detected.
.
(3) A hospital gave medicine which costs Rs 10000. But same medicine with different brandname was available at say Rs 1000. Today, it is had to detect and prove this. But with health card, hospital will have to eneter the medicine name, brand name, price etc in system;. So at any later date, system can tell patient and govt , with proof, that medicine-X costing Rs 10000 was given while Rs 1000 medicine Y with SAME components but different company brand was also available. Such record keeping is needed to control costs
.
So we need system where medicine / treatment / test data is recorded, but govt officers cant access without permission of patient. Such system can be made. This can be done by issuing multiple IDs to same person. So when person gives one or more of his IDs, then only doc or govt can see all his data, And govt officers who are in cross checking business (to ensure that there has been no leakages) will get only IDs, but no names.
.
Countries like Canada / UK have defacto health card ID since ages and ages. The citizens ther are NOT suffering due to health ID card. But other reasons.
.
For now, my request to activists is --- focus on ending lockdown ONLY. people like Vishvaroop Roy Gandhi, and usuk-elitemen-agents like David Icke etc will ask you to burn health ID card, so that lockdown goes on and on. (lockdown is still ON. eg mumbai local trains are closed, and passanger trains are only 2% of normal because 95% routes are not running !!! And those runnoing have expensive tickets and reduced tickets.)
.
Lockdown is breaking economy TODAY, and driving us towards slavery. Health card will take months to become effective. And given its plus points, you will become laughing stock in commons , if you oppose health card and tomorrow commons know about its plus point.
.
So people like Vishvaroop Roy Gandhi and David Icke may ask you to oppose Health ID card like headless chickens so that you dont get time to generate mass movement to end lockdown .
.
So pls focus on generating mass movement to end lockdown ONLY. Dont waste time after health id system. Lockdown is killing people TODAY. Health ID system will take months to come.
.
And to deal with MINUS points of health ID, solutions I propose are
.
(01) keep data keeping system, a person's data cannot be accessed by anyone without his permission, some OTP / encryption like mechanism can be kept for read persmissions. And in case person has met accident and has fainted, then in such emergency cases, data can be seen without his permission,. But system will notify him later which data was seen.
.
(02) keep data partitioned so that one govt officer or one doctor cannot see all the data,
.
(03) system records which data officer accessed and read, and each time anyone accesses data of a person, that person is notified.
.
(04) To prevent systemic misuse of power at apex levels --- Right to recall Central / State health Minister, Jury System over Staff , narcotest in public in case of serious misuses of data