Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
post 048 ; A082.048 ; Lockdown_only_use_damage
.
IMPORTANT ----- How Lockdown may be adding a few days in lives of some, but may be subtracting months from lives of many , by medical reasons ONLY (not counting those who died due to economic reason)
.
Lockdown is taking lives of many due to economic reasons. But lets consider ONLY medical reasons. Then also lockdown may be taking away lives of many. HOW?
.
My answer is
.
(1) say date is 01-mar-2020 and virus has come into main society
.
(2) Say A is weak and weakening, but still A has some ability to make new immunity and B has lost that ability
.
(3) Say no lockdown is imposed. Then say both A and B are infected. Then A will survive infection and B will pass away. And now corona-19 cant kill A for months and years.
.
(4) But say lockdown of about 2 months is imposed. Now some aged A will loose immunity. And so when lockdown is lifted, now A has weaker ability to make new immunity,. So A may also pass away. And so will B
.
IOW, lockdown delays interaction with virus, and so delays opportunity to fight against corona. And during this delay, many will loose ability to make new immunity
.
So even if we ignore losses due to economy, the lockdown may be adding some man days in soime lives and but also subtracts man days in many lives, because theri interaction with virus will not occur when they were strong.
.
So even in best case, lockdown is zero sum game only
..
======
.
( To fully understand this, one has to first understand what is immunity MEMORY and ability make new immunity. Full details are in link below.
.
-----
.
A summary of immunity MEMBERY and ability to make new IMMUNITY is as follows ----
.
(S1) Say a person is once. Say he had faced 100s of disease causing viruses and bacteria etc. And his body developed antibodies to fight against these viruses etc. Now bodyb somehow remembers that immunity for decades and decades.
.
(S2) But with age, and other factors, like diabetes, high bp, cancer medicines, heart medicines etc ability to make NEW antibody to fight against NEW bacteria or virus weakens,
.
(S3) So at any given point of time, there is some old/ill section in population, whose immunity MEMORY is still strong enough to deal with all seen bacteria/viruses ; but ability to make NEW immunity to fight NEW virus is now very very weak.
.
------ end of summary about immunity memory and ability to make new immunity -----
.
.
Full details of immunity memory --- https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10156950042956922