Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

post 039 , A082.039 ; Corona_Real , Immunity_Memory
.
Why corona deaths are real and LARGE in number? Because if a person's immunity is now near zero, then science has no way to save him from several viruses. But if immunity was very weak in so many of them, then how other could not kill them before 01-mar-2020?
.
Ans : Immunity MEMORY and ability to create NEW immunity are two connected but separate things !!
.
Pls read on for details.
.
And how does answer to this question help in dealing with lockdown issue?
.
Again, pls read on for details.
.
======
List of chapterts
.
(1) corona deaths are real and quite numerous
(2) What can be possible reasons
(3) why sudden increase in deaths after week-13 in UK?
(4) To what extent medication etc helps in corona-19 cases?
(5) So now back to lockdown question
(6) Summary
.
======================
.
chap - 01 : corona deaths are real and quite numerous
---------------------------------------------------------------
.
I will give some UK govt website data that shows that corona is indeed killing 1000s and lakhs across world. And may kill some 50000 to 3 lakh in India, And then see why despite this, lockdown serves no purpose !!!
.
average number of deaths in UK per week 11400. And in months of march, april, it is about 10700.
.
now, lets see deaths this year in mar-april
.
deaths in week-14 of 2020 = 16387 , 50% higher
deaths in week-15 of 2020 = 18516 , 70% higher !!
deaths in week-16 of 2020 = 22351 , double
deaths in week-17 of 2020 = 21997 , almost double
.
Across Europe, weekly deaths have increased by 50% to 100% for several weeks in a row.
.
So either it is due to factor that remains outside body like 5G radiations or due to some factor that goes inside body like a virus. But something real is indeed there. Otherwise, weekly deaths can NOT increase bt 50% to 110% for 4 consecutive weeks in a row in 10s of countries.
.
Now if deaths are due to 5G radiations , then solution for India is trivial ------ Right to recall health Minister, RTR Telecom Minister, Jury System over Health Ministry Staff, and Jury System over Telecom Ministry staff. That will end all 5G deaths and other 5G problems. And so lockdown isnt needed.
.
But say deaths are due to virus. Then some more questions need to be answered before we claim that lockdown is pointless.
.
==================
.
chap -02 : what can be possible reasons
--------------------------------------------
.
Now lets see agewise EXCESS deaths in week-15 of UK
.
age in years --- deaths in week-15
below 44 --- below 1 per lakh
45-49 --- 2 per lakh
50-54 --- 4 per lakh
55-59 --- 8 per lakh
60-64 --- 13 per lakh
65-69 --- 17 per lakh
70-74 --- 36 per lakh
75-79 --- 76 per lakh
80-84 --- 167 per lakh
85-89 --- 412 per lakh
90+ --- 1304 per lakh
.
So corona death increases SUPER LINEARLY with age !!!
.
Now consider virus like Rabies. It has very high fatalities across all ages, But here, this corona is causing far more fatalities to very elderly or persons who had consumed many medicines or have high bp or diabetes etc. Why is that so?
.
Well, one reason can be --- corona-19 is very weak virus and so it is able to harm only those who have very very weak immunity
.
But then here comes very imp COUNTER question. If their immunity was so so weak, then other pathogens should have killed them much before 01-mar-2020. So why that didnt that happen?
.
===> How come corona-19 can kill so many weak immunity people, but other much stronger viruses and bacteria were NOT able to kill them before 01-mar-2020?
.
This is very imp question , which must be answered before we can conclude that "corona kills only weak immunity people in UK and Italy"
.
For this segment of population as a whole, their immunity was decreasing GRADUALLY. So if low immunity is the only reason, then increase in death too should have been GRADUAL !! But there has been sudden increase in UK after week-13 and in Italy after week-11. Why is that sudden increase?
.
So imo, we need explanation to that, before we claim lockdown as inconsequential,.
.
===================
.
chap-03 : why sudden increase in deaths after week-13 in UK?
---------------------------------------------------------------
.
Here, imo, reasons are related to immunity MEMORY and ability to make NEW immunity
.
Say a person young and healthy once. He had faced 100s of disease causing viruses and bacteria etc. So back then, his body developed antibodies to fight against these viruses etc. Now most animal and plant bodies somehow remembers that immunity for decades and decades. So almost till death, that body is immune to those specific bacteria or viruses, unless at very very old age or very ill condition.
.
Now with age, and other factors, like diabetes, high bp, cancer medicines, heart medicines etc ability to make NEW antibody to fight against NEW bacteria or virus weakens,
.
===== IMPORTANT ====> So at any given point of time, there is some old/ill section in population, whose immunity MEMORY is still strong enough to deal with all seen bacteria/viruses ; but ability to make NEW immunity to fight NEW virus is now very very weak.
.
Since this is IMPORTANT, I will repeat -----------
.
=> At any given point of time, there is some old or very ill section in population, whose immunity MEMORY is still strong enough to deal with all seen bacteria/virus ; but his ability to make NEW immunity to fight NEW virus or bacteria is very very weak.
,.
So if his TOTAL immunity was weak, then 100s of pathogens would have killed him way before 01-mar-2020. But his IMMUNITY MEMORY was STRONG. But ability to make new immunity was very weak. So his body successfully defended against all "old" seen viruses. But the same body's ability to make NEW IMMUNITY was gone long back. So since no new virus namely corona-19 came in 01-mar-2020, body could not defend.
.
So problem is very real. We have a NEW virus in human population. Manmade virus or natural --- only narcotest of chinese lab scientists will prove, But since virus is NEW, no human has any IMMUNITY MEMORY against that this new corona-19 virus. So only defence is ability to make new immunity. So all those who have ability to make new immunity are safe. But those who have lost ability to make new immunity --- they are at serious fatal risk
.
=========================
.
chap-04 : To what extent medication etc helps in corona-19 cases?
-------------------------------------
.
Now to what extent can medication help in corona-19 cases? There is no medicine that ends virus growth to zero and eradicates virus completely in a body. Some medicine may reduce total viral load to say 1/10th but not 0. But again, these viruses will keep growing. And continued use of these high power medicines create other serious problems. Some medicines do reduce secondary infections. But finally, ONLY immunity works.
.
So medicine, oxygen therapy, ventilator all buy time,. They do add many days in life. But eventually, if body has lost ability to make NEW antibodies, then medicine and ventilators are no answers.
.
=================
.
chap-05 : So now back to lockdown question
-------------------------------------
.
Now comes the lockdown part. Lockdown of N days may delay virus visit by N days or less. And during this time, other pathogen can also kill,. Stable viruses like corona-19 can NOT be eradicated as many claim. So virus will visit all 136 crore people in India and 780 crore in world, and lockdown of N days will only at most delay the visit by N days, When visit happens, the ability to make new anti body is only main defence. So called herd immunity is also defence,. But herd immunity also only gets delayed by lockdowns.
.
Many could have done many right things before 01-mar-2020 or at least not done wrong things before 01-mar-2020. But lets take 01-mar-2020 as start date.
.
Now if ability to make new immunity is lost, then within 2-3 weeks, all medicines and therapies and ventilators at best add 2-3 weeks and become ineffective. Science is yet to find cure in such cases. And science is yet to create immortality too. I am sure one day science will make us all immortal. But today is NOT that day.
.
Now in India, virus will be far far LESS killing than UK, Thats because in India, many less immune people died long before 01-mar-2020 due to poor health care. Not that something we should be proud of,. We should rather be ashamed of, But it is fact that out of 1000 born in India, only 22 reach age of 80 years and in UK it is 106. So these 22 will have more IMMUNITY and the reason is NOT a good reason !!! And there are some other reasons why virus will be less potent in India, (see my other posts in this album).
.
========
.
chap-06 : Summary : why virus
--------------------------
.
I will again put agewise EXCESS deaths in week-15 of UK
.
age in years --- excess deaths in week-15
below 44 --- below 1 per lakh
45-49 --- 2 per lakh
50-54 --- 4 per lakh
55-59 --- 8 per lakh
60-64 --- 13 per lakh
65-69 --- 17 per lakh
70-74 --- 36 per lakh
75-79 --- 76 per lakh
80-84 --- 167 per lakh
85-89 --- 412 per lakh
90+ --- 1304 per lakh
.
This shows that virus is fatal to those who have lost ability to make NEW immunity and not fatal to those who have this ability. Now such population in India is very very low. WHY? Because if person has weak immunity, then poor hygine, poor health care, lack of money to buy medicine (for rank and file of population),. he would have passed away long before 01-mar-2020,. Only in West, which has good hygine and good subsidized health care can such weak immunity patient survive.
.
If we apply above rate over India and assume that pandemic will last for 6 weeks, tnen total deathcount in India comes as about 280,000 , which is about twice the traffic. But in other posts in this album, I have explained why potency of virus will be lower in India, and why spread rate will be lower even without lockdown. When we put all factors, the total corona death risk is below 50k. And Lockdown does NOT reduce it at all.
.
So lockdown is creating 100s and posibly 1000s of deaths. State Govts are NOT giving weekly agewise death data to see whether lockdown has INCREASED deaths or decreased deaths, and by how much non corona deaths have increased.
.
So finally, I will request all veiwers to decide whether they want to support or oppose lockdown. And pls send tweet "@PmoIndia #EndLockdown" or pls send "@PmoIndia # ContinueLockdown"
.