Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

Why I may NOT apply for common symbol for coming assembly elections
.
There are two SERIOUS problems
.
For first problem, pls see the ECI rules about symbols for recognized as well unrecognized parties - https://www.facebook.com/groups/RcmFiles/permalink/688910491545889/
.
( If you can download pdf on mobilephone FB app, then pls copy link of this status by clicking ... before this FB post, and using copy link feature. And then open the link in mobilephone Chrome BROWSER).
.
section-10B of this ECI rulebook applies to us. Its on page-7 and pag-8 for english and page-25 and page-26 for hindi.
.
the section-10b from first file says-
.
10B. - Concession to candidates set up by newly registered (unrecognized) parties and to unrecognized parties which were earlier recognized parties more than 6 years back. The candidates set up by a registered unrecognized political party at the general election to the Legislative Assembly of a State or to the House of the People, may be allotted a common symbol from the list of free symbols, subject to the fulfillment of the following conditions :-
.
(A) At a general election to the Legislative Assembly-
.
(i) The party sets up candidates at least in 10% ( ten percent) of the assembly constituencies in the State, subject to a minimum of five constituencies in States having forty or less seats;
.
(ii) The intimation with regard to the serial numbers and names of the constituencies concerned are intimated by the party to the Commission latest by three clear days before the date on which the notification (or first of the notifications in the case of a phased election) of the election is to be issued ;
.
(iii) The party shall give the names of ten symbols, in order of preference, from out of the list of free symbols notified by the Commission for the election;
.
(iv) The party also gives an undertaking that if the party does not set up candidates in the minimum number of the constituencies as prescribed in condition (i) above, its candidates shall not be entitled to allotment of a common symbol on the date of allotment of symbols to them; and, in addition, the party shall be liable for such punitive action as may be permissible under the law for making a false declaration before the Commission.
.
(B) At a general election to the House of the People –
......
.....
.
Explanation –
.
For the removal of doubt, it is hereby clarified that-
.
(i) the concession of allotment of common symbol to the candidates of a registered unrecognized party under this paragraph shall be only a one-time facility either at a general election to the House of the People or to a State Legislative Assembly, as the party may choose, and a party that has availed of this concession once shall not be eligible for
the concession in any subsequent general election;
.
===== end of portion from ECI rulebook ====
.
( I could NOT copy paste Hindi text from ECI rule book PDF. The text is getting corrupted --- so called unicode text problems. So for Hindi translation of above clause-10B, pls see the pdf )
.
This benefit of common symbol is available ONLY once to a Party. So as of now, I dont see any point in using it for coming elections.
.
===========
.
There is one more serious problem.
.
Also, pls see page-5 of the application form at https://www.facebook.com/groups/RcmFiles/permalink/688912604879011/ .
.
On page-5, I have to give undertaking that we will put candidates on at least 10% of constituencies in the sate !!! Now Maharashthra State as 288 constituencies. So I have to give undertaking that we will put at least 28 to 29 candidates !! Well, we dont have 28 activists in MH, forget candidates. And likewise, I have to give undertaking that
.
Also, this symbol allocation is ONE TIME ONLY till we become state recognized party. To become recognized party, we need to get 5% votes to 8% votes in the state. Thats a separate issue.
.
So lets consider coming three assembly elections in oct-2019 - Maharashtra , Haryana , Jharkhand . Maharashtra has 288 constituencies, Haryana has 90 and Jharkhand has 82. I have to give undertaking in writing that I will be able to put 29 candidates in Maharashtra , 9 candidates in Haryana and 8 candidates in Jharkhand. Punishment for not keeping such undertaking is NOT specified by ECI. But as of now, making such commitment is imo bad idea for me.
.
And lets consider Delhi Assembly elections of jan-2020. Delhi has 70 constituencies and I have to give undertaking that I will be able to put 7 candidates. This may be doable. But then also, we will get this common symbol for ONE TIME only.
.
So if I use this common symbol , then in future we will NOT get it till we become recognized party !!
.
So surely, for coming Maharashtra , Haryana , Jharkhand oct-2019 assembly elections, I am unlikely to use it I cant say for coming jan-2020 delhi assembly elections, but that too looks unlikely for now, unless I see some possibility that we may be able to 8% votes in Delhi.
.
So for now, chances are high that I MAY NOT apply for common symbol. I will decide in few days for sure. .....