Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

How anti-recall people spread LIES about deaths due to ending of oxygen in Gorakhpur Hospital
.
In order to sabotage campaign for RtrDeo3, JurySys3 etc, anti-recallists (sometimes posing as RTR-supporters !!) will cite many lies to create confusion that "RtrDeo3 etc law-drafts will ruin India" !!
.
One of the several such lies is
.
(1) One such lie is --- corruption in Gorakhpur Hospital which ended oxygen supply and caused death of over 100 children in few days was HIDDEN corruption. This is LIE. It was OPEN corruption known to almost all in staff as well as press, and many outside companies
.
(2) another lie they are spreading is --- Rtr-District-Health-Officer (a proposed law-draft is almost same as RtrDeo3) will increase hidden corruption !!
.
(3) So if RtrDho comes, then such deaths will ibncrease
.
I have already countered lie-no-2. That was easy because their analysis had lies.
.
But lie-1 is important. Their claim that oxygen supply ended due to HIDDEN corruption is lie.
.
The oxygen supply didnt end because staff was stealing 2 out of 100 cyliners or because staff was paying for 100 cyliners for 98 delivered. The oxygen supply ended because company which was supposed to supply liquid oxygen in bulk in large tanks stopped supplying. That company stopped supllying because hospital stopped paying them for months and months. The payment had stopped because the hospital chairman was asking for too much bribes. The liquid oxygen supplying companies many notices to hospital, press, health ministers, apex MLAs,MPs, CM etc. So IT WAS OPENLY KNOWN TO ALL that hospital isnt paying for oxygen delivered.
.
Finally, the oxygen supplying company stopped sending oxygen.
.
But in court, the company was forced to give statement that he had never stopped supply !! WHY? because law says that even if a govt hospital doesnt pay, the vendor cannot stop services !!! The vendor can approach courts and collect payment, but vendor is committing serious crime if he stops supply. If the oxygen supplying company were to admit in court, that it had stopped supplying oxygen, then owner will face case under IPS section-304 etc w, which says "homicide due to negligence" and he can face 10 years in imprisonment !! And so oxygen supplier gave a statement in court that he never stopped oxygen supply !!!
.
IOW, whole corruption was more than 100% open !! It was known to entire hosiptal staff and whole Goraphpur population that vendors have to give bribes to collect their right or wrong payments, and bribe shares go all the way to CM. So anyone who says "it was hidden corruption" is just a liar,
.
Now how would RtrDho, JurySys over Health/Hospitals and narcotest in public will reduce this mess?
.
Right to Recall District Health Officer will force DHO to create a system that makes payments regular or stop them only for valid reasons and no or negligible bribes. If he doesnt create such system, then voters will replace with DHO who has created such system in his district. Narcotest in public will ensure that in such high cases, Jury can dig out truth and find who is guilty and who is not. And Jury Trials will ensure prompt punishments. So fear of punishment, and fear that one cant get away -- will reduce crorruption as well as gross negligence.
.
Now will these laws stop a staff from stealing say 2 out 100 cylinders? My question is -- should activists waste time on such questions? Today, Chairman and staff take as much as 50% of payments as bribes !! RtrDho , JurySys and narcotest will reduce it to less than 2%. And will "officer must maintain good website" type clauses promoted by Transparency International reduce that 2%? NO. The only narcotest on public will reduce such 2% corruption.
.
So a whole body of false argument is built on lies that "Gorakhpur hospital oxygen ending case" was due to "hidden" corruption and RtrDho, JurySys3 etc will increase such hidden corruption !!!
.
Since year 2000, Transparency International has been paying activists across world, to promote "Transparency via good websites" as a FAKE alternative to Right to Recall , Jury System, narcotest in public etc. And they add many such lies in their campaign.