Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

why fake recallists make fake claims that "RtrDeo3 etc will ruin India because RTR has created instability in Peru" !!!
.
RTR has vastly reduced corruption in Peru. But it did NOT bring down corruption to USA levels, because Peru doesnt have RTR over Police Commissioner , Judges, Public Prosecutors etc. It has RTR over Mayors and City Councilors, who have tons of responsibility but no power.
.
eg Mayor in Peru has to reduce traffic problem. Peru like India has high land prices because of lack of wealth tax. Since land prices are high, shop-keepers are unable to buy more shops and employ salesman, So a an army of unemployed works as street hawkers. And street hawking worsens traffic problem. Also, due to high land prices, Mayor is unable to buy land needed to widen roads and add parking lans, and parking sports of taxicabs,. So taxcabs' park along roadside, and further woensen traffic problem.
,.
Now Mayor doesnt have power to print wealth tax law, not does Mayor have power to create a referendum for wealth tax. So army of street hawkers and cabs worsen traffic problem, and so Mayor has to take a side. If mayor facors hawkers and taxidrivers, then mayor will loose support of other voters, And if mayor decides to crack down on taxcabs parked along roads or street hawkers, then mayor gains support of general voters but will face recall initiatives from hawkers and taxidrivers who faced fines and lost their livelyhood. And solution is wealth tax that will benefit all groups except wealth land owners, but mayor has no power to print that law or call for national referendum on that law
.
To make matter worse, Peru has NEGATIVE recall, and condition that 51% voters can recall Mayor even if Mayor is most popular, i.e. Say mayor has support of 35% and no other candidate has support of 36%, then recall should NOT happen,. But flawed clause that "51% can recall" created instability.
.
This problem is NOT there with procedures I have proposed. I have clearly proposed that recall of X who has support of N% can happen ONLY one some Y has proven support of at least (N% + 5%) or (N% + 10%) . IOW, instability is impossible in my proposed procedure.
.
Despite, this some FAKE RECALLISTS cite Peru example to show that RtrDeo3 and other Rtr-drafts I have proposed will increase instability in India !!!
.
This is what I call as DISHONEST analysis , or rather DELIBERATE DISHONEST ANALYSIS !! It is similar to a case where person will deliberately give false diagnosis only to sell expensive medicines and hide real reasons and real medicines
.
SOLUTION?
.
Each time a person claims that "Rtr law has failed in XYZ country", pls google to get code for that RTR draft . You will see that almost all RTR codes use signature gathering and negative recall, and dont have Jury System. Thats why, even the first RTR codes I had proposed in 1998 did NOT have any signature gathering and had only positive recall, and no negative recall. And RTR under-performed in most countries because there was no Jury System to punish the expelled corrupt officer or even decide his guilt before of after expelling. In absence of Jury Trial, judges will cook up judgment and paidmedia will make such judgment issue. Thats why from day one, I have kept JurySys as integral part, though as separate drafts to avoid hoch poch.
.
So pls note that fake recallists' arguments about Peru etc are NOT applicable on Rtr?Jury drafts I have proposed.