Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
DhanVapasi is going to be BIG / HUGE -- bigger than Janlokpal Nonsense. So I request all activists to take a stand on it, stand on proposed VARIATIONS/amendments and stand on proposed alternatives, and also stand on proposed SPURIOUS VARIATIONS and alternatives !!
.
Dhanvapasi says --- (1) see section-25 -- it says sell all govt plots and also sell all govt owned mineral mines and (2) divide money recieved equally amongst citizens of India !!
.
Whereas MRCM is ---- (1) collect ROYALTIES from mineral mines and rent from govt plots (2) divide money received equally amongst citizens of India !!
.
The part-1 of DV is dangerous. Because, this will ensure that all minerals and govt plots of India will fall in the hands of Indian/usuk elitemen, and mostly usuk-elitemen as Indian elitemen are relative too too weak. And they will buy all these mines and plots for PITTANCE. So for 5 years to 10 years; a lot of money will flow in to people of India. But after that, they will make rents and mineral prices skyhigh and so all gains will become nil.
.
So I have made my stand clear on FB as well as twitter - I oppose DV proposal as it is today. I request all activist to use "@PmoIndia HashTagDhanVapasi" if they support or write "#iOppose #OpposeDhanvapasi" if they oppose existing Dhanvapasi proposal as given in pdf at https://www.dhanvapasi.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/DhanVapasiBill.pdf
.
Now next step for activists (who oppose DV), need to take is what alternative they support , alternatives they oppose and HOW THEY wish to campaign for amendments/alternatives? And here, opposing SPURIOUS PROPOSED ALTERNATIVES and spurious campaign methods is also important.
.
So first, lets assume that Dhanvapasi authors and heads of the Dhanvapasi movement have GOOD intentions, till proven other way. So lets propose amendments which can fix these flaws. And if the DV draft proposer refuse the amendments, then only we can claim that they have malafide intentions.
.
My proposal is
.
(A) Publicized proposed Dhanvapasi amendments
.
(A1) support proposed amendment that mineral mines cannot be sold, but maximal possible per tonne royalties should be taken
.
(A2) support the proposed amendment that govt plots cant be sold, but can only be rented for maximum lease of 25 years
.
(A3) Right to recall over DhanVapasi Commission Chairman
.
(A4) Right to recall over other Dhanavapsi Apex Officers
.
(A5) Jury System in Dhanvapasi disputes
.
(A6) Narcotest in public on high cases of corruption in Dhanvapasi
.
(A7) Clause that only a company 100% owned by Indian Citizens can bid for mineral mines and govt plots
.
(A8) Clause that those who have taken loans from PSU banks cannot bid for govt plots
.
(B) Publicize MRCM-law-draft, RTR/Jury-law-drafts. Pls vote at https://newindia.in/causes/Minerals3
.
The most imp reason why Dhanavapsi will pick up is because activists ignored away MRCM issue for over 18 years !! And if they still want to ignore MRCM for whatever reasons, then there is NO stopping of Dhanvapasi
.
(C) Oppose spurious additions and spurious proposals --- many are proposing SPURIOUS additions that "proposal must have clauses that officer will create a propose website !!" And some people use proposals to promote private websites,. Activists can consider all such claims. But if found wrong, then they should NOT take more claims from same person again and again.
.
-----------
.
above is copy of my 28-sep-2018 post at https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10155567307586922