Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
#Minerals3 - MRCM --- Mineral Royalties for Citizens and Military
.
(this status post almost whole copy-paste from my book 301.pdf written in year 2009, printed in year 2012. The link to book is given in first comment. The link to year 2012 post is also given in first comment. To support this law, pls vote on PM's websute at https://newindia.in/causes/Minerals3 . And pls take other steps mentioned in first comment).
.
----------------
List of chapters
---------------
.
(01) proposed MRCM-law-draft in short
(02) some details MRCM draft.
(03) dispatching mineral royalties
(04) MRCM draft at State Level
(05) how much is land rent?
(06) how much is spectrum royalties?
(07) how much is mineral royalties?
(08) effect of land rent collection
(09) effect of not collecting land rent
(10) Right to Recall NLRO
(11) The full complete draft of the proposed MRCM law
(12) last 2 clauses of MRCM-law-draft
(13) cost of dispatching payments to 110 crore citizens
(14) wont this decrease Govt income? NO
(15) west has no such MRCM law. Why do we need it?
(16) MRCM draft and human rights
(17) land rent and comparison with Communism
(18) ethical arguments wrt MRCM
(19) What great men said on rents/ownership of plots
(20) how can YOU help in bringing MRCM law in India?
(21) Exercises
.
========================
.
chap-01: MRCM draft in short
-------------------------------
.
The land rent over IIMA plot, JNU plot, all UGC plots, Ahmedabad airport plot, all airports plots and 10000s of such GoI plots and royalties from all minerals, coals and crude oil of India must go to we the Citizens of India and our Military and no one else. And royalty, rent must come directly, not via any schemes. eg say rents from GoI plots and mineral royalties in Apr-2011 was Rs 45,000 crores. Then as per the MRCM Gazette Notification I proposed, Rs 15000 crores will go to the Military and about Rs 300 will go to each citizen in his bank account.
.
If every citizen withdraws cash once or twice a month, this would need no more than 150,000 clerks all over India. Existing nationalized banks have over 600,000 clerks. So the distribution of cash is feasible.
.
The direct cash distribution MRCM draft would create may translate into an income of over Rs 8000 per person per year and also lowering of land/house prices. Per person, not just per family. And thus MRCM draft will reduce poverty, increase income and thus increase demands for goods. The increase in demand for goods will increase local industries and thus increase employment. The increase in local industries will improve engineering skills and this will improve weapon manufacturing So less poor Hindus will turn towards Christianity or Naxalism or both. And one year after this law passes, if 3rd child is born, then both the parents will get 33% less rent (those who already have 3rd child won't be effected). So this law will also control population..
.
======================
.
chap-02 : Some details MRCM draft
----------------------------------
.
(2.1) Right to Recall main officer
.
One of the clauses of the draft of MRCM GN says : “the PM shall appoint a NLRO (National Land Rent Officer), whom the citizens of India may replace using the following procedure ... ” . The replacement procedure is as follows
.
(clause-RTR.2) If a citizen of comes in person to his Talati's office, pays Rs 3 fee, and approves at most five persons for the NLRO position, then the Talati would enter his approvals in the computer and would him a receipt with his voter-id#, date/time and the persons he approved. The Talati will put the preferences of the citizen on PM's website with citizen's voter-ID number and his preferences
.
(clause-RTR.3) If a the citizen comes to cancel his Approvals, the Talati will cancel one of more of his approvals without any fee
.
(clause-RTR.4) If a candidate gets approval of over 43 crore citizen-voters in India, then PM may or need not expel the existing NLRO and may or need not appoint the person with highest approval count as NLRO. The decision of PM will be final
.
So the Right to Recall over NLRO will ensure that NLRO will be much less corrupt and will deliver the rent money to citizens.
.
(2.2) The NLRO will allocate plots which has been declared as property of the Citizens of India by a law or a National Jury verdict that specifically authorizes the NLRO allocate that land.
.
(2.3) Collection of rent : one of the clauses of proposed MRCM-GN says : “The Citizens of India hereby decide and declare that the plot of IIMA, plot of Gujarat Vidyapeeth Ahmedabad, plots of all IIMs and the plot of JNU is the property jointly and equally owned by the Citizens of India. These plots are NOT property of the State or the State of India or the Union of India or any other private/GoI entity, but these plots are property of the Citizens of India. Further, all the plots of all UGC funded universities and colleges not owned by private companies or trusts are declared as the property of the citizens of India. And all plots under Central Govt and Govt entities are also hereby declared as the property of the Citizens of India..
.
(2.4) Another clause says : all plots under following Ministries/Dept will also come under NLRO :
.
Ministry of Tourism
Airports
All buildings owned by Air India and Indian Airlines
IIMs, all UGC funded colleges and universities except science and engineering
Ministry Consumer Affairs and Public Distribution
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting
Ministry of Information Technology
Ministry of Rural Development
Ministry of Small Scale Industries & Agro and Rural Industries
Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment
Ministry of Textiles
Ministry of Tourism and Culture
Ministry of Urban Development and Poverty Alleviation
Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports
Planning Commission
.
(2.5) [About IITs, IISc etc : A separate Govt Order we demand says: --- All the IITs, NITs and IISc shall come under DRDO and the DRDO director shall be the Chief Officer of these colleges and shall appoint Deputy Chiefs in these colleges to run the day today operations. The colleges teaching science and engineering will come under Ministry of Science and will not come under NLRO. However, the excess lands which these colleges have will come under NLRO]
.
(2.6) For the unused land, NLRO will divide the land in plots of appropriate sizes as he seems most profitable rent wise. NLRO will hold auction for each plot. The conditions for auction will be as follows
.
The lease will be for 5, 10, 15 , 20 or 25 years as decided by NLRO. The lease shall never be more than 25 years
The bidders will give bids for monthly rent and bidding period which can be less than maximum lease period. So bids will be in (monthly rent , months lease) format. One person can submit multiple bids. Minimum lease period will be 12 months.
The weight of the bid will Monthly_Rent / log(Lease_In_Months). i.e. more the rent, higher the weight and longer the lease, lesser the weight.
.
The bids will be open
.
The NLRO will give the plot as per weight of the bids.
NLRO will charge 3 months rent as deposit.
8. During the lease time, the NLRO will revise the rent every 3 years based on % change in the land prices in the 1sq km area around that plot and % change in interest rate from the day the plot was leased and the day when rent revision occurs.
.
(2.7) After the lease time is over, NLRO will hold a fresh auction, where in existing lease holder will get following benefits.
(2.7.a) his weight will get multiplied by 1.25 to 1.5 depending on years he has paid rent.
.
(2.7.b) he may increase his bid within 1 month after auction is over.
.
(2.7.c) the existing lease holder will get 2 to 6 months new rent when he vacates.
.
(2.8) But if existing lease holder loses the auction, then he can move or sell the fixtures on that land. But he will need to vacate that land.
.
(2.9) If the plot is currently being used and occupied (eg IIMA plot), NLRO will take the mean land price in past 3 years of sale in 1 km area round the plot and decide the price of plot and set yearly rent as (market_price * prime_interest_rate/3) for next 10 years. The rents will be revised every 3 years. After 10 years, an auction as in clause-6 will be conducted.
(2.10) Dispatching rents : The NLRO will give 34% of the rent collected to Defense Minister for the purpose of strengthening Military and providing weapons and weapon-use education to all citizens.
.
(2.11) The NLRO will distribute 33% of the rent collected every month to the citizens born in that State or residing in the State for past 15 years, with maximum limit of twice the National per capita rent given last year.
.
(2.12) The NLRO will distribute the rest 67% the rent collected every month to the citizens of India
.
(2.13) 6. One year after this law is passed, the rent a person obtains
.
will increase by 33% if he has no kids
.
will increase by 33% if he has only 1 daughter
.
will remain at par if he has (1 son) or (1 daughter, 1 son) or (2 daughters)
.
will decrease by 33% if he has more than (2 daughters, 1 son) or (1 daughter, 1 son) or (2 sons) or (3 daughters) and in which youngest kid is born 1 year after the law is passed
.
will decrease by 66% if he has more than (3 daughters, 1 son) or (2 daughters, 2 sons) or (1 daughter, 2 sons) or (3 sons) or (4 daughters) and in which youngest kids is born 1 year after the law is passed
.
(2.14) The rent paid will be 33% higher for men above 60 and women above 55 ; and will be 66% higher for men above 75 and women above 70.
.
====
.
chap-03 : Dispatching mineral royalties
----------------------------------------
.
As of now, the mine plots are auctioned to the one who gives highest royalties. The same procedure will continue but may get modified later to improve the bids. But the one change MRCM Group demands and promises is that mine royalties and crude oil royalties will go to commons and Military directly.
.
===================
.
chap-04 : MRCM draft at State Level
------------------------------------
.
All plots under State Govt not used by Police, Courts, Military, Prison, Govt Schools, Govt Hospitals , State Transport bus stations and plots specifically exempted by law shall be up for rent collection. The State Land Allocation Officer shall collect the rents and give 34% to Military, 33% to citizens of India. Whether the land is under State or Center, the rent is divided in the same fashion.
.
=====================
.
chap-5 : How much is land rent?
-------------------------------
.
The Govt of India, Central and States, have 10000s of plots with huge marker value. Here is a small example
.
(for proper table, pls see section-5.6 of book 301.pdf , link given in first comment)
.
( format - plot name, area, price persq meter , plot’s marketvalue)
.
(pls note --- 1 acre = 4000 sqmt)
.
(1) IIM Ahmedabad
size = 100 acres
rate = Rs 40000 per sqmt
total price = Rs 1400 crores
.
(2) IIM Lukhnow
size = 200 acres
rate = Rs 20000 per sqmt
total price = Rs 1600 crores
.
(3) IIM Lucknow (Noida)
size = 10 acres
rate = Rs 50000 per sqmt
total price = Rs 200 crores
.
(4) IIM Kolkata
size = 135 acres
rate = Rs 20000 per sqmt
total price = Rs 1000 crores
.
(5) IIM Indore
size = 190 acres
rate = Rs 15000 per sqmt
total = Rs 500 crores
.
(6) JNU
size = 1000 acres
rate = Rs 40000 per sqmt
total price = Rs 16000 crores
.
(7) Gujarat Vidyapeeth
size = 25 acres
rate = Rs 40000 per sqmt
total price = Rs 400 crores
.
(8) Gujarat University
size = 250 acres
unit price = Rs 35000 per sqmt
total price = Rs 3500 crores
.
TOTAL PRICES OF ALL EIGHT PLOTS ----- Rs 27000 crores
.
(please note that above land prices too less compared to real market price as on may-2009. The prices today may be 5 times)
.
so what shall be the rent if these plots are given out to builders? Rent of the nine plots at 3% of market value of plot = Rs 27,000 cr * 3/100 = Rs 810 cr a year = over Rs 7 per citizen per year. And these are just 8 plots, that too price I took is lowball of may-2009 price when this book was written. Today's price is about 5 times and so rent from these 8 plots alone can be Rs 35 per citizen.
.
Now these 8 plots are no where as valuable as many other prime plots such as Mumbai Airport, Ahmedabad Airport, Bangalore Airport etc. Here are more examples
.
(1) Ahmedabad Airport
size = 1850 acres
rate = Rs 40000 per sqmt
total price = Rs 29600 crores
.
(2) Mumbai Airport
size = 1100 acres
rate = Rs 100000 sqmt
total price = Rs 44600 crores
.
(3) Delhi Airport
size = 5000 acres
rate = Rs 100000 sqmt
total price = Rs 200000 crores
.
(4) Bangalore Airport (new)
size = 4050 acres
rate = Rs 10000
total price = Rs 32400 crores
.
(5) Banglr. Airport (old)
size = 1000 acres
unit price = Rs 100000
total price = Rs 40000 crores
.
(6) Calcutta Airport
size = 1500 acres
unit price = Rs 30000 per sqmt
total price = Rs 18000 crores
.
(7) Chennai Airport
size = 4800 acres
rate = Rs 40000 per sqmt
total price = Rs 76800 crores
.
TOTAL price of above 7 plots = Rs 440800 crores
.
So what shall be the rent if these plots are given out to builders? Rent of these airport plots at 3% of market value of plot = Rs 440,800 cr * 3/100 = Rs 13,224 cr year = Rs 120 per citizen per year !!
.
And pls note, the above price shown is too less compared to real market price as on may-2009 when this article was written. The prices in year 2018 would be at least 5 times)
.
The Union Govt of India has about 50000 plots by one estimate. Even if rent from each plot is as small as 20 paise per person per year on an average, the rent exceeds Rs 12000 per person per year. To that, add plots owned by State Govts and Local bodies.
.
So either we commons will get this rent or land prices will drastically decrease. Imo, what will actually happen is --- huge decrease in land prices, land rents and house rents. This will enable us commons to buy homes etc at lesser % of our incomes and start businesses.
.
=========
.
chap-06 : how much is spectrum royalties?
----------------------------------------
.
The lease cost of 3 spectrums – 2G, 3G and S-band was over Rs 200,000 for 20 years. If the spectrum is not leased for 20 years but rented and rent is taken year-wise, assuming 6% interest, EYI (equated yearly installment) would be over Rs 15,000 crore or Rs 120 per citizen per year (not per month). Now there are just three spectrums --- all spectrums added may give about twice the rent.
.
=======
.
chap-07 : How much is mineral royalties?
---------------------------------------
.
The mineral royalties estimation is possible, but varies as the selling prices fluctuate. Here is an estimation based on jun-2008 prices. The estimation uses following method, which are borne from laws I am proposing. As per laws I am proposing, the mines and oil wells will be leased using competitive bidding. So the charge miners would charge will be rock bottom low and will depend on prevailing labor wages in India and cost of equipment. Now in the laws I am proposing the Govt would charge international selling price from the buyers. The difference would be royalty of which 67% will go to citizens directly and 33% would go to the Military. Following is my estimate of crude oil royalty based on Jun-2008 prices
.
Crude oil
------------
.
Oil international price = US$140 per barrel
.
Extraction price in India = below $25 per barrel including all costs.
.
(as on jun-2008 oil companies charge $55 per barrel and make huge profits which becomes loss due to buying oil at $150 from international market. $25 is price Indian oil companies were charging in early 2000s to Indian refineries. To that add the fact that Indian oil companies are hugely over staffed and over pay their employees. eg clerk in ONGC gets about Rs 20000 including all perks and expenses while clerk in private gets Rs 8000 or so. This expenses can be decreased).
.
production in India = 660,000 barrels per day= 24 crore barrels per year
.
population = 110 cr
.
per capita Production in India = 0.22 barrels per Indian per year
.
profit per barrel = US$ 115
.
total profit in dollars = 0.22 * 115 = $25 dollars per Indian
.
dollar price rate = Rs 45 per dollar
.
so profits in rupees = $25 * 45 = Rs 875 per common per year
.
If crude oil prices drop to US$ 70 per barrel, then profits will reduce to about Rs 250 per citizen per year.
.
---------------------------
.
Iron Ore
-----------
.
production = 123 million tonne = 12.3 cr tonne
= 0.11 ton per Indian citizen
.
price = 150 dollars per tonne = Rs 7600 per tonne
.
mining cost = Rs 300 per tonne
.
profit per tonne = Rs 7200
.
profits per common = 0.11 * Rs 7200 = Rs 730 per year
.
IOW, if crude oil is given to refineries at International price, and profits are dispatched to every Indian, every Indian will get Rs 875 a year. This will decrease as oil prices decreases and will increase if oil price increases. This was just crude oil. The royalties that come from coal, natural gas, granite, marble, kota stone, copper, alumina, iron ore and waters also form sizeable amounts. Once citizens know that they are getting mines’ royalties, they will curb the mine mafias and this will enable honest people to enter the mining business and thus royalties will increase by several folds. As per my guesses and estimates, the mine royalties will exceed Rs 4000 to Rs 6000 per person per year
.
So mine royalties and land rents will add to about Rs 18000 per person per year. Of this 33% will go to Military. So the citizens will get about Rs 12000 per person per year. This money is not dole, it is money from the plots and minerals we citizens own. The money is not coming from any tax. There is no “tax the rich, feed the poor” proposal. It is simply about minerals and plots that we citizens own.
.
The MRCM draft is the mother of all changes. We are proposing other changes only to bring this change and to ensure the change stays after bringing it. As of today, land rent and creation of new M3 are the principal two reasons why we commons are poor. The forth demand shall reduce us commons’ poverty.
.
=========
.
chap-08 : Effect of land rent collection
---------------------------------------
.
Once the land rent act is enacted, one of the two things will happen ---
.
1. either we commons will gain say Rs 500 to Rs 1000 per person per month of land rent OR
.
2. the price of land will fall, as renting makes hoarding very expensive
.
The latter is more likely. Now if price of land falls, then housing price will fall, which will improve quality of the lives of us commons --- many of us commons who live in slums will be able to move to say 1BHK flats. And if price of land falls, number of businesses will rise (since as real estate cost drops, it becomes easy for craftsman to expand), and we commons will have far more jobs and better salaries. Higher industrialization would increase the mineral prices, and so the mines’ royalties will increase. So in any case, the proposal of land rent from IIMA plot, other IIM plots, JNU plot and 10000s of plots and mines we commons own is bound to benefit us commons by a substantial amount.
.
So land rent and mine royalties proposal will create incomes, reduce poverty, improve land and houses availability to the poor and middle class. Thus it will increase purchasing powers of the poor and middle class. The increase in purchasing powers will increase demands and thus increase industries and which will increase employment and skills. And it shall also strengthen our Military.
.
=====
.
chap-09 : Effect of not collecting land rent
-------------------------------------------
.
The effect of not collecting is plain injustice, exploitation of poor via rich and unfair increase in economic equality. eg Consider airport plots. Consider Delhi Airport. It serves 2 cr passengers a year. It has rent value of Rs 6000 cr per year. i.e. Rs 6000/2 = Rs 3000 per passenger. Consider an eliteman who used the Delhi airport 20 times in a year. But by not charging him land rent of Rs 3000 per flight, his richness increased by Rs 600,000. And every common of India lost Rs 60 per year as he did not get any land rent from the Delhi Airport plot he owns. This only increases the wealth/income gap by unfair means of rent denial.
.
========
.
chap-10 : Right to Recall NLRO
------------------------------
.
The rent is to be collected and dispatched by officer titled as National Land Rent Office (NLRO). The rents will be determined by standard calculations based on market prices and interest rates, so NLRO does not have discretionary powers there. But he does have some discretionary powers in deciding the process of making sub-plots. So what would stop NLRO from siphoning all the rent into his pocket? Well, the forth MRCM demand , promise has clauses which shall enable us commons to expel/replace NLRO. These replacement system is the key that shall enable us commons to find an NLRO who believes in dispatching rents to us commons.
.
=======
.
chap-11 : The draft of the proposed MRCM law
-------------------------------------------------------------
.
for main clauses, pls see https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10155448208991922
.
for complete draft. pls see -- https://www.facebook.com/groups/RcmFiles/permalink/534996790270594
.
====
.
chap-12 : please note the last two clauses of the PM-RP law I have proposed
-------------------------------------------------------------
.
(chap removed )
.
====
.
chap-13 : cost of dispatching payments to 110 crore citizens
-----------------------------------------------------------
.
(not relevent anymore --- still, if you wish to see this section, then pls see link to the book in the first comment)
.
========
.
chap-14 : wont this decrease Govt income? NO
----------------------------------------------
.
If all mineral royalties go to citizens, wont Government fall short of funding?
.
First, as per my proposal, the 33% of mineral royalties do go to Government (Military), which can be seen as 33% income tax on every common and his income from mineral royalties and land rent. Now this 33% will INCREASE after 67% goes to citizens. How?
.
Consider mineral royalties today. Today, for a granite block that is worth Rs 100 in market, whose extraction and transportation cost is below Rs 10, Govt gets royalties of Rs 5 or even less. Why are the bids so low? Because the local mining contractors hire criminals to ensure that more miners cannot come and bid in the Collectors’ offices to submit the bids. But the criminals are able to operate ONLY because they have support of MLAs, MPs, Ministers, CMs, PM, IPS, IAS and relative lawyers of the judges. IOW today, using criminals, MLAs, MPs, Ministers, CMs, PM, IPS, IAS and relative lawyers of the judges ensure that lions’ share of deemed royalties come into their hands via the mine contractors and criminals they bless. Now today, I activists were to tell commons that commons should fight against these Ministers, IPS, IAS and judges’ relative lawyers, then two key questions arise –
.
(a) how can a common fight? and
.
(b) why should a common risk his lives or spend time to do so?
.
The name MRCM-Recall answers both these key questions. MRCM answers the second question : if mineral royalties are going to citizens then the citizens have reason to ensure that criminals who stop good mining contractors getting killed or imprisoned. And the Recall answers the first question : using Right to Recall over Policemen, judges, CM etc the citizens can ensure that police chiefs, judges, Ministers who promote criminals are replaced ASAP by individuals who are pro-common. So “MRCM-Recall” will increase the mineral royalties to several fold, and that will also increase the royalties that Military gets. Thus, the sum total of govt income from minerals will increase from MRCM, NOT decrease.
.
In the same way, consider the issue of Govt plots. Today, PM, CMs give away a large number of GoI plots for a price fraction of market price. The Right to Recall CMs, RTR-PM provides means by which citizens can stop this. And MRCM i.e. giving land rent to commons and Military gives a reason to citizens to stop this. Every time, a CM, PM rents out the land for rent below market value, the citizens will feel a loss, and when the loss exceeds some tolerance amount, they will spend Rs 3 file for an approval and replace him. Or better, fear of replacement and subsequent punishments will put a check on CMs, PM while doling away lands for bribes. So the net rents will increase and so the 1/3rd of the rent that goes to the Govt (Military) will also increase.
.
So MRCM-Recall proposals increase the net Govt incomes from minerals and land rent – they do not decrease it. It also increases the incomes of the commons. Then who loses? The criminals and mine contractors will be small losers --- the real losers will be IPS, IAS, Ministers, CMs, PM, super elitemen who own huge mine, relative lawyers of judges etc. And those who oppose MRCM-Recall proposals, are only benefiting the criminals, mineral ore contractors, IAS, IPS, relatives of judges, super elitemen who own huge mines etc and no own else. Many intellectuals are on their payrolls and so vigorously oppose MRCM-Recall proposals to serve their interests.
.
=====
.
chap-15 : West has no such MRCM law. Why do we need it?
-------------------------------------------------------
.
I have been campaigning for the procedures by which we commons can expel PM, CMs and judges. All eminent intellectuals have opposed this demand and tried tooth and nail to show that it is unconstitutional. Having failed, they say “West does not have this procedures to give Royalties to commons and so why should we have this procedures?”
.
Well, US has income tax of 40% to 50% with low evasion and few exemptions. US also has about 1% wealth tax on lands. And US has 45% of inheritance tax upon death. The taxes are used for welfare schemes and benefits do reach commons, as Jury System has ensured low corruption. The Indian intellectuals opposed wealth tax, high income tax and is dead against inheritance tax and so funds allocated to welfare is next to nothing. And Indian intellectuals also killed Jury System in 1956, and so corruption runs amok and funds get siphoned out. I have proposed 30% income tax, 2% wealth tax and 35% inheritance tax to improve Military, Military Industrial Complex, engineering education and general education needed to manufacture weapons. And I have also proposed Jury System to reduce corruption so that delivery improves and poverty reduces. But this method of reducing poverty and poverty deaths will take years. Whereas giving mineral royalties to us commons directly, reducing poverty and poverty deaths is possible within mere 4 months.
.
=======
.
chap-16 : MRCM draft and human rights
-------------------------------------
.
(mo this chapter isnt relevent anymore --- still, if you wish to see this section, then pls see link to the book in the first comment)
.
=============
.
chap-17 : Land rent and comparison with Communism
---------------------------------------------------
.
Many equate the MRCM proposal to give mineral royalties and land rent from GoI plots to commons with Communism. The MRCM proposal has nothing to do with Communism. Following are the differences
.
(1a) MRCM was first proposed in oct-1998, but the proposal that land rent from private as well as Govt plot should be collected and divided amongst all citizens was given by Thomas Paine in 1790, some 28 years before Marx was born
.
(1b) Marx was born in 1818, and words such as Marxism , Scientific Communism etc came into existence into 1850s
.
(2a) MRCM confines to Govt owned plots and minerals, and has nothing to do with ownership of factories. In fact, MRCM encourages private ownership of factories so that bid amounts for plots and minerals increases
.
(2b) In Communism Govt owns all factories.
.
(3a) MRCM is a coded proposal
.
(3b) Communism is a vague concept and has dozens of meanings, and none has procedure code attached to implement it.
.
(4a) In MRCM , rent directly goes to citizens.
.
(4b) In Communism, the land is given to a Govt unit and is either not collected at all, or when given to private body, it is collected and used by discretion of Ministers, officers, judges.
.
Suffices to say that there is no similarity between MRCM and communism.
.
=========
.
chap-18 : Ethical arguments wrt MRCM
-------------------------------------
.
I explain ethical issues wrt MRCM as follows : Consider a pond where 1 crore liters of rain water falls every year and there are 100 persons in the village. Who should get how much of water? Since no one does any labor to fill the pond, no one has more right than others and thus all have equal rights and thus all should get 100,000 liters per year. By same logic, each citizen has equal rights over mineral royalties.
.
The ethics over distributing land rent on Govt plot is as follows
.
Say a person owns a plot/flat. Then who should get rent coming from that plot/flat? Obviously the owner
Say the plot/flat belongs to 10 persons, then who should get the rent? Obviously, all 10 in the ratio of their ownership.
Say the plot/flat belongs to some large company like Reliance with say 3 crore shareholders. Then who should get the rent from that plot/flat? Obviously, all 3 crore shareholder in the ratio of their ownerships.
.
Now consider plot of Delhi Airport. It belongs to 120 crore commons of India. And so the land rent should come to all of us 120 crore commons.
.
Now are citizens owner of the Delhi Airport plot or is Govt or State of India owner of that plot? I don’t want to argue this question. If someone says that the plot does not belong to citizens of India, and belongs to State or India or Govt of India, I have only insults, no arguments, for him. After all, if someone walks into your home and tells you that your home doesn’t belong to you, then IMO, you will offer insults and not argument. Same way, I claim that all non-private plots in India are property of us 120 cr commons of India, and if anyone differs, I have only insults for him.
.
But to keep courts out of it, I propose that citizens should force MPs to add a line in Constitution which declares citizens as joint owners of all non-private plots. Once this line is added in Constitution, the debate will formally end.
.
========
.
chap-19 : What great men said on rents/ownership of plots
-----------------------------------------------------------
.
Atharvaved says : Aham Rashtrim Vasunam Sangamani i.e. I the nation own the natural resources. Thomas Jefferson, the second President of USA said
.
"It is a moot question whether the origin of any kind of property is derived from nature at all... It is agreed by those who have seriously considered the subject that no individual has, of natural right, a separate property in an acre of land, for instance. By an universal law, indeed, whatever, whether fixed or movable, belongs to all men equally and in common is the property for the moment of him who occupies it; but when he relinquishes the occupation, the property goes with it. Stable ownership is the gift of social law, and is given late in the progress of society." --Thomas Jefferson to Isaac McPherson, 1813.
.
The founding father of USA, Thomas Paine, in 1790, in his landmark essay Agrarian Justice said that rents from ALL plots, be private or Govt owned, should be collected and divided amongst citizens !! So ownership of land is something that has been very controversial topic since long and many great men have opined that Govt plots belong to all citizens equally. MRCM is an extension of that idea.
.
======
.
chap-20 : How can YOU help in bringing MRCM law in India?
--------------------------------------------------------
.
Please read chap-13 of this book rahulmehta.com/301.pdf . It has several steps where-in you can spend 4 hours a week and help to bring Right to Recall law-drafts in India.
.
=======
.
chap-21 : Exercises
--------------------
.
(1) How much was crude oil production India in 2008? Assuming cost of production did not change in 2008 from that in 2006, and if $135 per barrel was collected from buyer, how much money would citizens of India get, as per your estimate? And if $50 per barrel was collected from buyer, how much money would citizens of India get, as per your estimate?
.
(2) What is the land area of Mumbai airport? What is the approximate price per square meter? How much would citizens of India get if rent is 3% a year of the market value?
.
(3) What is land area of the largest university in your district? .
.
(4) How is approximate price of the plot and rent per citizen of India assuming rent rate of 3% of value a year?
.
(5) Does Indian Budget consider land rent deemed as subsidy?
.
(6) Why do intellectuals of India insist that we commons MUST not get mines’ royalties directly and get it only via schemes?
.
(7) Why do intellectuals of India insist that we commons MUST not get land rents directly and get benefits only via schemes?