Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
GST can be 28% plus cess , and there is no limit on cess. So bringing petrol under GST need NOT reduce prices
.
Many commons think that if petrol is brought under GST, then since highest tax rate in GST is 28%, the taxes on petrol will reduce from existing 100% to 140% to 28% and so petrol prices will fall !! This shows the extent to which paidmediamen, defunct leaders like SoMoKe and corroks like congress/rss/aap leaders have MISINFORMED commons.
.
There is NO upper limit on tax rate in GST-law-draft. The 5%, 12%, 18%, 28% are STANDARD rates, but there can be any amount of cess on the product. . eg there is cess on several categories of vehicles, which makes effective GST rates on them much higher than 28%
.
If petrol etc comes under GST, then only change will be -- prices across India will be same, and cess/rate etc cannot change without approval of GST council which is dominated by Central Govt.
.
The price of petrol depends more on tax money govt needs. GST from pother goods is reducing, income tax collection has not shown any major increase and govt expenses keep rising. And leaders dont want to levy taxes on land and improve collection of mineral royalties. And so govt has no option but take high taxes on petrol.
.
So imo, taxes on petrol are linked with (govt expenses minus how much taxes can come from other sources), and not whether petrol comes under GST or not. All these paidmediamen, leaders like SoMoKe and congress/rss/aap workers are only fooling people by making statements that "bring petrol under GST so that petrol prices reduce" !!