Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
(1) Good DEO website is useful/needed DOES NOT mean "clause in law stating DEO shall make good/useful website" is must/needed/useful
.
(2) "clause in law stating DEO shall make good/useful website" is absent does NOT at all mean "DEO will NOT make good/useful website". Whether DEO will good website or not depends on punishments he is likely to face and powers he has to put information, and funds/skills he has.
.
(3) Only a MALICIOUS activist will say "see this, this law has clause that DEO shall make a good website and hence if this law is printed, then good website will come".
.
(4) Only a MALICIOUS activist will say "see this, this law doesnt have clause that DEO shall make a good website and hence if this law is printed, then good website will never come".
.
The presence/absence of a clause may or MAY NOT have some effect or zero effect. One needs to analyse how much effect mere addition of clauses can make. If mere addition/absence makes zero effects , then addition of such clauses is only spurious.
.
-------
.
One of the biggest fallacy in law and legal reasoning is --- assuming that mere presence of clause will ALWAYS change behavior or change reality and mere absence of clause will NEVER change behavior or change reality.
.
And such claims are often exploited by malicious leaders and fake activists across the world, to promote their useless variations and stall others' useful proposal
.
This can be STRAWMAN FALLACY or FALSE DILEMMA FALLACY.
.
For other fallacies prevelent in law and legal reasoning, pls see https://thebestschools.org/magazine/15-logical-fallacies-know/
.
-----
.
My proposed RtrDeo3-law-draft doesnt have clause that ":DEO shall promote good history education, good maths education, good science education" or "DEO shall promote scientific modern temperament and nationalism in education". .
So one can propose an VeryEffectiveRtrDeo draft by taking RtrDeo3 and adding following clauses :
.
(1) DEO shall provide good maths education
(2) DEO shall provide good science education
(3) DEO will give education which created good moral values
(4) DEO will give education which increases nationalism
(5) DEO will ensure that all classes have blackboards
and so on and on
.
And next, he can make claims "see, RtrDeo-law-draft will enable parents to replace Deo, but it will NOT improve maths/science eductaion and will not improve moral values and natioanlism". So students after printing RtrDeo3-law-draft will become traitors, immoral, weak in maths/science etc etc. Where as VeryEffectiveRtrDeo-law-draft has clauses that DEO shall give good maths/science education, good moral education and natioanlis,. So if VeryEffectiveRtrDeo-law-draft is printed, then and then only students will become patriotic, nationlist, strong in maths/science etc etc
.
So where is such reasoning flawed?
.
The flaw is -- creating an impression that mere presence of clause is going to bring changes !! And mere absence of clause will NOT bring those desired changes and absence of clause will automatically bring undesired changes.
.
So pls dont get impressed by GREAT features "promised" in proposals. Pls only look at -- what PROCEDURES CITIZENS have? What powers does the law-draft give to voters? Only these procedures will force officers to give proper information on paper or on website, and give other facilities. The statements in law-draft dont make much changes in behavior or reality.
- https://thebestschools.org/magazine/15-logical-fallacies-know/
- https://external-ord5-2.xx.fbcdn.net/emg1/v/t13/13786008214543558997?url=https%3A%2F%2Fres.cloudinary.com%2Fhighereducation%2Fimage%2Fupload%2Fw_740%2Ch_416%2Cc_fill%2Cf_auto%2Cfl_lossy%2Cq_auto%2Fv1%2FTheBestSchools.org%2Flogical-fallacies.jpg&fb_obo=1&utld=cloudinary.com&_nc_sid=c97757&_nc_ht=external-ord5-2.xx.fbcdn.net&stp=c0.5000x0.5000f_dst-jpg_flffffff_p500x261_q75_tt6&ccb=18-1&_nc_gid=xBK7gw8bvoR11dBp8oN3Dw&_nc_zt=3&oh=06_Q3_DAdhzJUra3pXnchK2Q_n7ocLrh3665zEZkbFIuMY_5hbi&oe=6AC2C1DD