Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

FAKE credit grabbing --- right to recall clauses and JurySys clauses will improve govt websites, and NOT other way. But many are making FAKE claims that govt websites will improve RTR / Jury !!! what are THEIR MOTIVES?
.
eg1. say a law-draft says "Mineral Dept Minister/Secretary shall put all mineral royalty data on web", Tata pays coal royalty of Re 1 per year per ACRE on a Jharkhand coal mine since 1946 !!! Now will this clause bring this royalty detail on govt website? Lets see. A a nefarious minister/officer with nexuses will start putting data where mineral royalties are taken properly, and then he will claim "see, I dont have time, money and staff to put all data on web all in one day, and so pls give me some time to put all data" . And thus ensure that Tata Re 1 per acre per year data comes on web after years and years or almost never comes on web.
.
eg2. : worse, say an officer starts putting data like Tata's re 1 mine, but could NOT upload all data due to lack of time, monet and staff. Then nexused high court judge can pull him and ask "did you upload all past 10 years data as law asked you to do"? Obviously, he upload such huge data in short time. So HCj can order his transfer.

eg3. say law-draft says "Land records dept Minister/Secretary shall put all land ownership data data on web". Then a nefarious minister/officer will start putting data of small plots and then he will claim "see, I dont have time and money and staff to put all data on web all in one day. And so he will almost never upload the fact that Godrej alone has 16 crore sqft land in Mumbai alone !!!
.
eg4. Say an honest officer tries to put information about massive land holdimgs. Then HCjs can pull him and ask "did you put ALL information pon web as law says"? Obviously, this isnt possible in few months. So HCj can order his transfer.
.
-------
.
A govt website is useful only if it shows ALL relevant information in PROPER way, and puts more relevant information at top and has search by relevant keywods.
.
Even if and when good officers come, it will be MONTHS before they can put up all relevent data. So in meantime, the more important data should come first and less important data should come later. Because all data cannot be put scanned, digitized and uploaded in few months.
.
So it is necessary that officers upload more important data first.
.
All this is HIGHLY subjective.
.
-----
.
There are already enough govt directives saying that that all important information should come on net. So why hasnt PM or CM or any Mining Minister or any Mining Secretary displayed this information in PROPER way on any govt websites? Imo, thats because we dont have RTR over Mining Minister and dont have Jury Trial over Staff.
.
So imo a statement in law-draft like "officer shall put all data on web" is useless, because in such case, a nefarious officer can start putting useless data first, and then claim "see, I dont have time , money and staff to put all data". And then he can ensure that useful data never comes on web !! So citizens can look at all websites, and will never see any useful data.
.
And worse, the website clause can used by High court judge to harass a honest officer. Say a new DEO has come afdter RtrDeo. Then after say 6 months, the High Court judge can call him and ask "did you pout 10 nyears data on website as law says". Now of course he accomplish that. And so judge can then harass him
.
============
.
Also, some people are putting a fake argument that "see, this website clause will automatically that a good website will come with all relevant information " !!!
.
Thats sheer nonsense
.
Important information will come on govt websites ONLY after RTR/Jury comes over officers. Till then, websites will keep showing huge amount of useless data and keep useful data off. eg govt already keeps a lot of mineral royalty data on web !!! Try finding royalty Tata pays on his coal mines. You will never find it, because its not there or kept in almost unreachable manner.
.
So adding clauses like "officer must put 10 year data on website" adds no value to RTR/Jury drafts, and worse, such clauses can enable Higher officers/Ministers/judges to harass/transfer good officers
.
========
.
So now if a good website comes, credit should go to RTR?jury clauses. But some "activists" want to do opposite. They want to give credit to "good website should come" for performance of RTR/Jury clauses., obviously he is making FALSE statements,
.
And obviously, they have some nefarious motives.
.
The motives are --- they want credit of saying "see, RTR/Jury clauses and procedures were all useless and damaging, and we are the ones who are making them all useful". Its worse than man adding some paint on a mercedes , even when no paint was needed, and then clainming that he made whole mercedes !!
.
And thats evident from posts, Whole 25 page draft is copied, and then two para are added, post copier doesnt inform reader that 25 pages were copied from elsewhere !!! This is just credit grabbing and nothing more.