Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
(incomplete - pls comment after completion. comments posted will be deleted.
.
Dear all recallists
.
There are activists, calling themselves as recallists, claiming that almost all RTR-law-drafts proposed by me are bad and will damage India if they are passed. And at the same time, their claim is --- the very same 1 page draft or 50 page drafts magically become good drafts after their proposed 2-4 clauses.
.
So I request ALL to take following steps
.
(1) pls ask them FIRST to make their stand clear on original proposed-law-drafts
.
A proposed-law-draft-X is bad if and only if India's situation is likely to WORSEN from EXISTING situation, if that proposed-law-draft is printed. Claims like "proposed-law-draft-Y is better than proposed-law-draft-X" does NOT make proposed-law-draft-X bad. Because new better proposed-law-drafts will always keep coming, as technology improves and more people work to propose law-drafts.
.
So pls ask hem to put their claims in CLEAR WORDS first. Are they claiming that existing proposed law-drafts such as RtrDeo3 etc are "bad" in their opinion?
---
.
(2) So a claim that "a proposed-law-daft-X is bad" means that claim-maker is saying that situation of India will actually worsen India along one dimension , say manufacturing or education or crime etc , if that proposed-law-draft is printed. So again, pls take a CLEAR statement from them
.
----
.
(3) To explain that a proposed-law-draft is "bad, one has to give one or more SCENARIOS which will arise if the draft is printed and situation worsens from existing