Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
Can elitemen using paidmediamen damage even 1% of the 3 crore Jury Trials across India? imo, NO ; with ALL their money they have, they cant influence even 1 out 10000 small cases, or medium cases or large cases !!! How / Why?
.
In existing judge system, elitemen manage to influence almost 99% of cases thru bribes and nexuses, and hierarchy. So all those who are claiming that #JurySys3 will do damage to India --- I dismiss them as LIARS.
.
==============
.
(A) Summary :
------------
.
One of many arguments anti-Jury pro-judge people across India give against my proposed #JurySys3-law-draft, given at newindia dot in /causes/JurySys3, is that elitemen will manage to get "bad" judgments from Jurors using paidmedia campaigns ; and so #JurySys3 in India should be brought ONLY after their proposed pre-conditions and co-conditions are first met !!! Or rather , JurySys3-law-draft should not be brought at all.
.
Anti-JurySys3 people will not give their estimate of what % of the 3 crore cases can be effected by paidmedia campaigns , and how much would that cost, and whether elitemen have that kind to money to begin with. I request activists to look into NUMERICAL SCENARIOS and PAIDMEDIA COSTS, That will prove that claims that #JurySys3 will do worse than existing judge system are all false.
.
Here, I will show that their claims that elitemen can influence Jurors via paidmedia campaigns is a LIE. My method is simple --- show costs of district / state / national level campaigns, and show that they can NOT fund such campaigns for even 0.01% of the 3 crore cases.
.
==============
.
(B) why paidmedia campaigns almost ALWAYS fail in Jury Trials
----------------------------------------
.
Lets take some REAL examples.
.
(B.1) A recent example is Jury Trial where Jurors imposed fine of about $270 million on Monsanto company for not putting warning labels that their herbicide spray liquid has cancer causing chemicals. Monsanto regularly pays paidmediamen to write that their chemicals are harmless. But many doctors were able to present cases of humans as well as rabbits / mouses, which convinced Jurors that chemicals do cause cancer. Monsanto could NOT prevent doctors.etc from talking to Jurors. So mediamen's reports did indeed effect Jurors. But effect got washed away, when doctors .presented their opinions.
.
(B.2) Another example was McDonald hot coffee case of 1994. The Jurors imposed fine of about $3 million because McDonald kept selling coffee at 88 degrees centigrade, while McDonald's own Dermatologists had warned the company that the chances of third degree burns increases after 75 degree centigrade (and chances of third degree burns are neglible below 75 degrees tempreture) if there is a spill by accident. But McDonalds kept selling super hot coffee because it was increasing profits. After fine, McDonald immidiately ordered all its outlets to improve warning labels, and also reduce tempretures, thereby stopping further injuries. And here too, McDonald tried its best to use paidmediamen to convince Jurors that super hot coffee is harmless for skin. But McDonalds could NOT stop doctors from presenting their arguments in court. And simple arguments and reports of dermatologists were sufficient to inform Jurors about obviuous damages that super heat coffee causes. All in all, the paidmedia campaign failed..
.
(B.3) So why did paidmedia campaigns failed?
.
(B.4) Because in Jury Trial, both parties get opportunity to present their statements. And paidmediamen can also present their paid stories. But paidmediamen can NOT stop either party from presenting their side to the Jurors.
.
----> Paidmediamen mostly succeeds by ensuring that paidmediamen can make audience see what paidmediamen have to say, and other side gets near zero coverage. If other side gets coverage, then paidmediamen will mostly fail to convince their fake stories. But in Jury Trial, each party gets almost equal time in court, and paidmediamen too get some time, to influence Jurors. But there is no way for elitemen to ensure that one side gets zero time. And so paidmediamen campaigns fail to convince falsehoods Jurors.
.
Thats why, paidmediamen are successful in twisting elections in large constituencies. But a candidate cant reach all lakhs and crores voters without paidmediamen. And so paidmediamen decide which one to project. But same paidmediamen fail in local panchayat level elections, because here candidate can reach all voters and so paidmediamen lose their monopoly.
.
Same way, in Jury Trials, paidmediamen cant stop either side from REACHING Jurors. And so paidmediamen fail.
.
===========
.
(C) Costs of paidmedia campaigns limits number of cases they can influence
To run a district level paidmedia campaign, the costs are Rs 10 crore to Rs 50 crore, say average of Rs 20 crore.
.
To run state level paidmedia campaigns, costs are Rs 100 crore to Rs 500 crore depending on size of state and nature of issue. Say average is Rs 200 crore.
.
And consider national level campaign like campaign used for JLN aka Janlokpal Nonsense, The paidmedia costs were of the order of Rs 10000 crore. Lets take average national level campaign cost as Rs 2000 crore
.
You may take any other numbers you wish. But pls dont take small numbers like Rs 1 crore for district level media campaign etc. Such numbers are too unrealistic
.
Now there are 3 crore crore pending cases. Say some 2.80 crore as small cases, some 19 lakh are medium cases, and some 1 lakh are large cases. You may take any numbers.
.
The small cases will mostly end at district level, medium cases will end at state level and large cases may go to state / national level.
.
There are about 600 districts, and so there will be about 40000 small cases per district. If district decides to clear all cases within 5 years, then each will run about 8000 cases per year. And one case will take about 2 weeks. So some 500 courts will be created. And Every month, some 1000 - 1500 cases will be resolved, and in 1 year some 15000 to 18000 cases will be resolved. And in 5 years some 80000 cases will be resolved in each district.
.
And all cases are separate parties. And most cases will be based on different laws and issues.
.
So one campaign CAN NOT effect several cases. This important to note, and so I will repeat. One district / state / national campaign cannot effect too many case. So elitemen decide to influence Jurors using paidmediamen, then they will need to raise paidmedia campaign round the year.
.
So say it tales Rs 20 crore to run a district level paidmedia campaign. There are 280 lakh small cases. So to influence all of them, elitemen will be Rs 5600 lakh crores !!! This is almost 28 times the whole GDP of India. To influence even 10% cases, they will be Rs 560 lakh crore rupees, which is almost 2.8 times the whole GDP. And to influence even 1% cases, elitemen will need Rs 56 lakh crore --- almost 25% India's GDP. (GDP of India is about Rs 200 lakh crores)
.
How much money can elitemen spend after paidmediamen?
.
GDP of India is Rs 200 lakh crore The total advertisement spend across India across print / tv / net was Rs 70000 crore in year 2017-2018. So how much can elitemen spend for paidmedia campaigns?
.
My estimate -- no more than Rs 2 lakh crores a year i.e. at most Rs 10 lakh crores in 5 years. Then how many district level campaigns can they run? Each district level campaign would cost Rs 20 crore. So they can run at most Rs 10,00,000 / 20 = 100,000/2 = 50000 campaigns only. So out of 2.80 crore district level small cases, they can run campaign for only 50000 cases i.e. less than 0.25% cases
.
So in 99.75% cases, elitemen wont be even able to run any paidmedia campaign. And in 0.25% cases, where they did manage to run paidmedia campaigns, in most cases, when other side puts facts, the effect of media campaigns may get washed away.
.
So FINALLY, how many cases can elitemen effect by burning money on paidmediamen? Imo, it is coming below 0.01%
.
Also, elitemen may be able to spend Rs 2 lakh crore a year, as of TODAY. Once MRCM comes, their nefarious incomes from minerals will be less than 5% from what is today. And once MRCM and wealthtax comes, the value of their plots will be 10% of what it is today. A big portion of their nefarious income --- lands and minerals will reduce by 90% to 95%. So they wont be able to spare even Rs 20000 crore for paidmediamen. And with that, they cant run even 1000 district campaigns a year, and so using paidmediam, they cant influence even 0.01% of all 2.80 crore small cases.
.
The NUMERICAL analysis for meidum and large cases will be almost the same.
.
The medium cases will to go to state level.To influence a state level case, the state level paidmedia campaign would cost Rs 200 crore on an average to elitemen. There will be some say some 19 lakh middle level cases. The cost to run paidmedia campaigns for all these cases will be Rs 3800 lakh crores, almost 20 times the whole GDP of India !! With budget of Rs 200,000 crores a year, they conduct campaigns for only 1000 cases i.e. only 5000 cases in five years !!!
.
And again, MRCM and wealthtax will crush their ability to come up with so much money. Most they will be able to spare is Rs 20000 crore a year. And with that, they can barely run 100 state level campaigns in a year and 500 in five years. So in 18,99,500 cases, there will be zero paidmedia campaign. And in 500 cases, where they have have paidmedia campaign to influence Jurors, they cant stop either sides from presenting their arguments. So final success rate will be below 0.01% cases or even lower.
.
And same analysis is for large national level 1 lakh cases
,
===============
.
(D) Tcp can overule Jury verdict
------------------------------------------
.
And in #JurySys3 , a judgment of Jurors can be overturned by Tcp. So elitemen may need to influence half the whole population of district / state / nation, and that too in 1000s of cases. How much money is needed to influence lakhs / crores of voters? Well, even if elitemen get all wealth of India multiplies by 10, they cant run so many campaigns
.
==============
.
(E) How elitemen get high success ratio in judge system?
-------------------------------
.
It is using powers of supreme court judges over 20000 lower court judges !!!
.
So elitemen dont always bribe all 20000 lower court judges, They do, but some 5% to 10% may go otherwise. Then supreme judges are used to bring them in line.
.
So in judge system in India, apex elitemen only need to cover 30 SCjs.
.
But in JurySys, all 3 crore Juries are independent.
.
===============
..
(F) My conclusion:
-------------------
.
cost of district level campaign = Rs 20 crore
cost of state level campaign = Rs 200 crore
cost of national level campaign = Rs 200 crore
number of small district level cases = 2.80 crore
number of medium state level cases = 19 lakhs
number of large national cases = 1 lakh
.
say all cases will be resolved in 5 years
.
India's TOTAL GDP = Rs 200 lakh crores per year
India's total ad spend tv, print etc = Rs 70000 crore per year
Money elitemen can spend after media = ATMOST Rs 200,000 crores per year
.
(Money they will be able to spare after MRCM / wealthtax comes = Rs 20000 crores atmost. But lets take Rs 200,000 crore for now)
.
Money elitemen can spend for paidmedia campaign in 5 years = Rs 10,00,000 crores at most
.
number of small cases they run campaign for = Rs 10,00,000 crore / Rs 20 crore = 50000 atmost = 0.2% = 2 out of 1000 !! So in 998 out of 1000 small cases, they wont be able to even run a campaign.
.
number of middle level small cases they run campaign for = Rs 10,00,000 crore / Rs 200 crore = 5000 atmost = 0.3% = 3 out of thousand !! So in 997 out of 1000 small cases, they wont be able to even run a campaign.
.
number of large level small cases they run campaign for = Rs 10,00,000 crore / Rs 2000 crore = 500 atmost = 0.5% = 5 out of thousand !! So in 995 out of 1000 small cases, they wont be able to even run a campaign.
.
And in 5 out of 1000 cases, where they might be able to have campaign ---- what are the chances that campaign can actually turn Jurors' opinions? Subjective, but neglible,.
.
So objective part is --- in 995 out of 1000 Jury Trials, elitemenj wont be even able to run a paidmedia campaign !! And chances that their paidmedia campaign can effect Jurors in 5 out of 1000 cases are also small.
.
IOW, effect of elitemen's paidmedia camapains on 3 crore Jury Trials across India will be = less than 5 out 1000, or may be less than 1 out of 10000 !!!
.
Now compare that with 99.99% success elitemen have in judge system !!!
.
So my point is ---- those who claim that #JurySys3 will worsen India compared to EXISTING judge system --- I dismiss that as a LIE.....