Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

why / how Modiji = Yediji may win MLAs' support in Karnataka? Buying MLAs is easy and anti-defection is defacto weak till oath is taken. SOLUTION? Direct election/recall of CM (see last para)
.
Now, I have ZERO inside information. I am applying logic on PUBLIC information and what we saw in past, such as how RSS = BJP (*) managed to buy 12 MLAs in Rajsabha election in Gujarat in sep-2017. Also, I am NOT jyotish. So I am not predicting --- only citing a likely scnario.
.
(* = I consider RSS and BJP same, and it is my personal belief and I am not stating it as fact. Just as many people believe that shaktimaan and gangadgar are same)
.
Also, I am NOT taking sides. Solution I propose is activists should work to force congress / rss / aap MPs to print laws that will enable voters to DIRECTLY elect CM, directly expel CM using Right to recall CM and bypass MLAs. As long as MLAs are electing CMs, we will see buy/sell and worse, we may even start seeing murders.

Now lets talk of drama we will see at 4pm today
.
Karnataka has 224 MLAs, and 2 elections were postponed. And JDS apex leader Kumarswamy contested from 2 seats and won both. But he can cast only one vote and not two.
.
So we have 224 - 2 - 1 = 221 MLAs voting. Protem speaker can morally and legally cast his vote. So RSS = BJP (*) needs 221 / 2 = 111 votes, or rather (221 - absent)/2 votes. And absent and abstain have same effect. Abstain means physically present, but didnt cast his vote.
.
So RSS has 104 MLAs and because of raw threat of CBI and Income Tax raids, all will show up and vote for RSS CM Sri Yediyuruppa.
.
Now there are 2 independents and 1 BSP. Mayawati may want BSP MLA to vote against RSS, but anti-defection will not apply for now. So BSP MLA may or may not sell out. And if he sells out, he has NOTHING to lose. And if he doesnt sell out, then Modiji may use income tax raids and CBI on him. So I am betting that BSP MLA will sell out. And so may two independents. They are EASY sales, because MLAs have nothing to lose.
.
So RSS has now 104 + 2 independent + 1 BSP = 107.
.
So now RSS needs to purchase only 4 congress / jds MLAs or convince 8 congress / jds MLAs to abstain. eg if 8 MLAs abstain, then number of votes casted will 221 - 8 = 213, and so RSS will neeed 213/2 = 107 votes, which it may get.
.
Now some 8 to 10 congress / jds MLAs were in RSS = BJP till 2 days before filling congress candidate form !!! They have no connection with party or ideology. In fact, other than bribe gathering, congress / jds (and rss / aap too) have no ideology left. So imo, it is trivially easy for RSS = BJP to bribe such 8 to 10 congress/jds MLAs and convince them to abstain or even cross vote for RSS. Also, many congress / jds MLAs have income tax violation cases, customs violation cases, excise violation cases and CBI cases and assorted criminal cases against them. So it is trivially easy for Modiji to convince them by arm twisting them, as well as offering them release in such cases, and also offering them payments as icing on cake.
.
So RSS can buy 3 easy MLAs, 4 difficult MLAs or convince 8 to abstain. And so RSS wins CM election round one.
.
The anti-defection law does NOT apply till first meeting or house and oath is taken. Because as per anti-defection, the MLA is expelled if he violated the "whip" i.e. order issued by an apex MLA, who is appointed as "whip" by the party. As of now congress / jds have appointed no whip, because they cannot appoint any whip became whip can appointed only after first meeting of house !!! So none of the congress / jds MLAs have recieved any whips or order. So if they abstain or remain absent, the punishment is legally zero. And even if they cross vote and vote for RSS CM Yediyuruppa, then also punishment is doubtful.
.
After RSS wins, and Yedi becomes CM, congress may bring no confidence motion and in that motion, whip will apply. But all that is later. Right now, RSS will focus on winning first round.
.
Now entertainment will NOT end. Sequel of movie will come within week.
.
Because immidiately after first house meeting, if Modiji = Yediji wins, congress/jds will bring no confidence vote. And now anti-defection will apply. So it is difficult but not still impossible to buy MLAs. So now RSS = BJP will need to convince 8 congress/jds MLAs to resign or engineer split in jds/congress. If there is split, then drama will end. But if 8 MLAs resign, then fate of Yedi govt will depend on outcomes of these 8 bye-elections and so we will see a real big drama in these by-election. IOW, there are too many possibilities on how things may evolve.
.
SOLUTION?
========
.
Solution I propose is that activists should realize that congress/rss/aap leaders are all frauds and made up of same clay. Activists should work to force MPs to print law by which voters can directkly election CM and directly expel CM using Right to recall CM. As long as MLAs have power to elect CM, MLA buying will go on and on
.
I have uploaded the law I have proposed for OPTIONAL direct appointment of CM, directly via voters and recall by voters, as newindia.in/RtrCm . Pls for congress/rss/aap workers to provide link to their solution DRAFT to this MLA selling problem. And pls compare it with solution I have proposed.

If you WHAT CAN YOU DO TODAY TO INCREASE POSSIBILITY THAT THIS LAW WILL COME IN INDIA?
.
(1) Ask congress/rss/aap workers to upload the SOLUTION DRAFT they propose on newindia dot in and give link
.
(2) Pls compare draft given by them with solution I have proposed at https://fb.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10154897589176922
.
(3) If you prefer the solution I have proposed, then you can take following steps
.
(3a) pls VOTE at newindia.in/RtrCM . newindia dot in is central govt website
.
(3b) pls tweet " @PmoIndia #AllCmStates print Right to Recall CM law proposed at newindia.in/causes/RtrCm 0fb83071a2dbaa8301814d1af72496f499103d95 . Voter can approve 5 candidates for CM position and change approval anyday. If most approved has 10% more approvals than existing CM, then CM changes "
.
(3c) pls create a photo album on your wall named as "law draft I support"
.
(3d) pls share the draft given at https://fb.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10154897589176922 , above tweet and link newindia.in/RtrCM on that album
.
You can increase the POSSIBILITY that this law will come in India.