Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

How privatization monopoly reduces efficiency of NATIONAL economy
.
Say there is railway station. Say there are slots for 100 shops and say all have equal value to vendors i.e. for any vendor, he will pay same rent to any slot.
.
(a) Station master decided to keep rent as Rs 10000 per month. There are 110 applicants.
.
(b) And so he decided to raise rent to Rs 13000 per month. And he found that there were only 90 applicants.
Total rent = 90 * Rs 13000 = Rs 11,70,000 per month
.
(c) And so he decided to raise rent to Rs 12000 per month. And he found that there were only 95 applicants.
Total rent = 95 * Rs 12000 = Rs 11,40,000
.
(d) And so he decided to raise rent to Rs 11000 per month. And he found that there were exactly 100 applicants.
Total rent = Rs 11,00,000 per month
.
What is best option for owner? (b)
.
What is best option for society? (d) !!!
.
Say rent left after expenses of station is to be divided equally amongst all citizens. Even then, (d) is best option for society, because it maximizes employment , competition, total output etc.
.
So any private company will opt for (b) and not (d).
.
This is why you see expensive coffee at airport and yet large amount of vacant space. The private company which maintains airport deliberately keeps space unallocated so that number of slots for shops are less. And so higher rent can be collected !! To society, that is lose lose situation. More and more customers will bring food from home adding to inefficiency, And employment at airport will be below maximal.
.
But if company is govt owned, and citizens have RTR/Jury over apex/staff, then citizens can force thet apex/staff to take option (d).
.
Now here, monopoly like Railway Station or Red Fort or Taj Mahal are NOT created by private companies. In fact, except patents, there is no way private company can have a long lasting monopoly because employees of the that company themselves will quit and soon become new suppliers !!
.
Monopolies like Taj Mahal or Red Forts are due to historical reasons or rather historical wrongs.Monopolies like Railway Station are created by Govt's power to confiscate or acquire land to build railways. Unlike companies like Microsoft, who once had monopoly in Operating System, Railway Stations or Taj Mahal are NOT any private individuals' own hard work or risk.
.
So when such monopolies are privatized, the owner will earn EXTRA profits even though contribution was made by people of past or people of present.
.
------
.
We see that companies like ITC, Dalmia etc are very eager to jump into such monopoly business. They claim that they have more talents and so they will do better jobs at maintaining monopolies. Well, why dont these companies use their talent to make Microsoft, Facebook. Google etc?
.
All in all, these companies never had much merit or talent. They were good ONLY at bribing Ministers and IAS and running oiligopolies, and buying silence from paidmediamen.
.
Can any person bid for Red Fort?
.
NO. One can make huge profits at red fort etc by making hotels and restaurants there, But these are heritage sites and so commercial use of land will be on paper prohibited. So only a person who is capable of twisting the contract and get away can earn huge profits. IOW, if a bidder has deep contacts with judges, IAS, paidmediamen etc then he can make commercial use of land and get away. But an person who doesnt have nefarious contacts will NOT be able to earn huge profits. So when monopoly is put for bid, the elitemen who have more nefarious contacts will be able to put higher bids.
.
Now SoMoKe (SoMoke = Soga/NaMo/ArKe , one and same, they are slaves of foreign masters) and CoRaAp ( = congress/rss/aap workers, again one and same, they are in politics ONLY to collect bribes). are eager to orivatize red fort, taj mahal, all railway stations etc. They shout loudly that govt employees are immanageable and indisciplined and so privatization is must. Their end goal is to hand over all monopoly assets to foreign companies. WHY? The usuk-elitemen own media, and usuk-elitemen promise that they will show ONLY SoMoKe and CoRaAp as alternatives, if SoMoKe and CoRaAp agree to hand over sector by sector of economy to usuk-elitemen.
.
SOLUTION?
.
Solution I propose to activists to work to bring Right to Recall over Ministers law-draft and Jury System over Govt employees law draft. I am yet to upload draft for "Right to recall Minister" . Meanwhile, if you want to help the Right to Recall movement, you can support RTR-PM draft. The link to RTR-PM-draft is https://newindia.in/causes/rtrpm2. Description of the proposed law is at https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10154897547041922
.

.