Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
#NarcoTestInPublic1 - Narcotest in Murder and serious violence cases , uploaded at newindia dot in/NarcoTestInPublic1 . Pls see links in comments
.
---------------
NarcoTest in Public Act – Narcotest in Murder and serious violence cases
.
comment : Once this act is passed, the judges or Jurors will be able to ask accused or complainers to go on narcotest, with their approval. And the test will be optional for them. But in cases involving extreme violence, the judge or Jurors may decide to force accused but not others to take the test. The judge or Jurors will decide whether narcotest will be in public or confidential i.e. done before court in camera. When done confidentially, the portion disclosing name of victim will be removed and rest of the audio/video will be made public. The questions will be decided by judge or Jurors, with help of policemen and experts. The answers given in narcotest will NOT be taken as evidence.
.
---------------------
.
[ comment : This narcotest law-draft needs to be passed in Loksabha and Rajyasabha with simple majority, and passing this law needs no amendment in Constitution.
.
Important clauses are – (1) , (2) , (8)
.
This narcotest law can be passed after or without passing JurySys law . The Jury System law is given at newindia dot in/causes/JurySys2 ( hash = 8ba4b283fc2674f4281189b2019245975f0ee17c )
.
The “comments” listed here are not binding on any Officer / Minister / judges. The Jurors , Citizens and all can use it as guidelines. But they are not binding. ]
.
(1) The judge or Jurors can ask accused, complainer, witness to undergo (a) polygraph test or (b) brain-mapping test or (c) narcotest or more than one of these 3 tests or all of these 3 tests in any order. If it is Jury, then all decisions will be taken only if over 75% of ALL Jurors agree. The test will be optional, except in cases of (2)
.
(2) In cases of extreme violence, the judge or Jurors may make one or more of these tests compulsory on the accused without his permission, but not on witnesses or complainer.
.
(3) The judges or Jurors will decide whether the test (i.e. lie detection or brain mapping or narcotest) will be conducted in public or confidentially. If done confidentially, then after test, the portions disclosing names of female victims will be removed and rest of audio/video will be put in public.
.
(4) The judge or Jurors will NOT ask him irrelevant questions, not connected with any crime committed. The judge or Jurors will decide the question using help from policemen and experts.
.
(5) If Jury System is used, then Jurors will be divided into two groups. One group will write questions, and second group will accept or reject question with majority vote
.
(6) The judge or Jurors will NOT use the statements as evidences. But policemen can use the statements to discover more evidences.
.
(7) The test will be conducted by a doctor chosen by judge or Jurors , from a list of approved qualified doctors. The list will be prepared by CM.
.
(8) comment : A nonbinding guideline for judge or Jurors is – (a) before test, they can listen to witnesses, complainer, accused, see material evidences and decide if test needs to be taken (b) if they decide to take test, then first they should take polygraph test, then brain mapping and then narcotest (c) also, judge or Juror may decide to first take narcotest confidentially, then again publicly, or may decide to take just one narcotest.
.
(9) Appeal : The decision of judge or Jurors in a court can be cancelled by judge or Jurors in a higher court.
.
(10) PM thru Gazette Notification can suspend this act for a group of district or group of state for 4 years.
.
(CV) Citizens’ Voice:
.
(CV.1) If any citizen residing anywhere in India wants any change in this law or has any complaint under this law, then he may submit an affidavit to DC’s designated clerk and clerk will scan the affidavit on put on PM’s website along with photo and details of the citizen. The clerk will charge Rs 30 per page. The clerk will issue serial number for the affidavit.
.
(CV.2) If any citizen wants to register his YES / NO on the affidavit submitted in above clause, then he can go to Talati’s office and provide the serial number of the affidavit and his YES/NO on a form, and Patwari will enter his YES/NO for a fee for Rs 3 . The YES/NO shall come on PM’s website along with citizen’s voter-id, name, date etc The YES / NO count will not be binding on PM or any officer etc. PM may enable citizen file YES / NO using SMS or APP.
.
===== narcotest in public =====