Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

#SscPaperExams #NoSscOnlineExams

If you support paper exams and oppose online exams in SSC and other Govt recruitment exams, then vote on this cause. NewIndia dot in is PMO's website, and NOT any private website.

In the proposal, the question paper will be sent to exam hall just 10 minutes before exam and will be printed in exam hall. And right after the exam, each candidates’ answer sheets will be immediately scanned in exam hall put on public website. And each candidate will get xerox of their answers. No online exams.

If you oppose online exams for govt jobs and support paper based exams, then pls vote on above cause, and share COPY this status on FB.
.
https://newindia.in/causes/sscpaperexams/
,
And pls send following tweet as well

@PmoIndia #CmAllStates #SscPaperExams #NoSscOnlineExams https://newindia.in/causes/SscPaperExams … , pls take SSC and all recruitment exams using paper. Print question paper in exam hall. immediately put candidates’ answers public website. Candidates get xerox of their answers. No online exams
.
PaperSscExams - Proposed method to take Paper based, and not online, Recruitment Exams for Govt Department

=======
.
Here is THE FULL proposal on how exams can be taken

==========
.
.
Introduction
--------------

(1) Vande Mataram. This writeup is NOT a proposed a law. It is a proposed method to take recruitment exams. The method proposes paper based examination method, where over ONLINE exams. Here (a) question paper is printed in hall (b) students give answer on OMR or paper (c) immediately after exams, answers are scanned and uploaded on public website (d) students get xerox copy of their answers. And this writeup explains why this method is superior to online testing

(2) The activists can decide whether they support this exam method or other exam method. If they support this paper based exam method, then they can decide which activist method wish to use to convince PM/CMs to use this examination method.
.
.
Details of this method
---------------------------

(3) SSC (or any testing body) will use hall of large size where at least 200 candidates can sit. Each candidate must be on a single person chair. Hall will have CCTV camera with live feed going on youtube for all halls. So if 200,000 candidates have to give exams, then SSC may need 1000 such halls, or lesser halls if halls are bigger in size.

(4) Each hall will have 2 PCs, 3-4 large printers, 3-4 heavy duty scanners and also xerox machines

(5) The hall incharge will get question paper in PDF format over secured connection over internet just 10 minutes before exam. Say PDF file is 8 pages. Then he will need to print 8 pages * 200 copies = 1600 pages in that room and distribute the paper to the candidates

(6) The candidates will get A4 size OMR sheet, and supplementary sheets of A4 size.

(7) If the questions are MCQ, then he will need to select the application spot on OMR sheet and also write the question number, answer choice and line from answer choice on the supplementary. For non-MCQ, the candidate will need to use answer sheets as usual.

(8) For MCQ, the system will take OMR as main input. But his answers and handwriting supplementary may be seen and used to decide if there was any wrong doing

(9) In addition, students will get envelope of A4 size

(10) Moment the exam ends, each student will need to put OMR sheet and all answer papers in the envelope

(11) The hall in-charge and staff will then scan all OMR sheets and all answersheets right in the hall and immediately put all the data on PUBLIC website right away. The students will also get a xerox copy of their OMR sheets and answer sheets there and there. So say each candidate has written say 10 pages. Then hall in-charge and staff needs to scan about 11 * 200 candidates = 2200 pages.

(12) All candidates and anyone in world will be able to download answers of any or all candidates for a small charge to cover networking costs.

(13) Results can be announced after a few days, as applicable.
.
.
Why imo Online testing is useless
---------------------------
.
(14) In online testing, if SSC server administrators get bribed, then they can replace candidate’s actual answers by correct answers and increase his chance of selection, and no one will know. There are software tools which enable person physically close to machine to change data on disk without login !! One way is to booting the PC using DVD , and then change the data on disk in a way that after change no forensic audit can prove tempering !!

(15) Another method is – if owner of testing software installs a remote login software on the PC, then a well learned can login on the candidate’s PC and see all questions and answer,. The candidate can simply pretend that he is clicking answers, while the cheater on remote terminal and click all answers

(16) Another way is – cheater can remote login on the router between testing center and server. By this, he can trap the data coming from candidate’s PC and he can change data of just 1-2 candidates and keep other data as is. So those 1-2 candidates will get more marks

(17) In short, there are innumerable “touch-points“ in online testing. So online testing is good when stakes are low such as primary class maths exams. But if testing is to give Govt jobs or recruitment in apex bodies or promotions etc, then imo online testing is open invitation for corruption and ideological filtering

(18) Ideological or Political Filtering : what is worse than corruption in online testing is ideological or political filtering. If the apex in-charge of testing body belongs to Ideology-A or Party-A and he wants to ensure that only candidates of ideology-A or candidates affiliated with Party-A to get selected, then without taking any bribes, he can do so. Thru social media , party rosters and other means, can obtain which candidates subscribe to which ideology or party. And by tempering data on server, he can replace answers given by chosen candidates by correct answers. And thus he can increase the chances of those candidates getting selected. Ideological Filtering or Political Filtering imo is more dangerous than corruption. And so I oppose online testing

(19) What is important in recruitment is NOT just honesty, but every lay outsider should be able to see and also verify that there was no foul play. In online testing, outsider can never feel sure whether insiders hacked the candidates answers or not, and whether candidates terminals were rigged or not. But paper has not be hacked till date. So imo outsiders may feel more assured with paper instead of online testing is used
.
.
Activism
-----------
.
(20) Each candidate or activist needs to decide whether he wants SSC and other Govt bodies to use this paper methods or use online testing. If he decides to support this paper method, then I request him to take following steps

(21) On link https://newindia.in/causes/PaperSscExams pls click ‘vote now’. You may have paste his link twice

(21) PM is the Minister incharge of SSC. Pls see website of Dept of Personnel and Training. So pls send following tweet to @PmoIndia ‘@PmoIndia #CmAllStates #SscPaperExams #NoSscOnlineExams https://newindia.in/causes/SscPaperExams , pls take SSC and all recruitment exams using paper. Print question paper in exam hall. immediately put candidates’ answers public website. Candidates get xerox of their answers. No online exams ‘ .

(22) Pls ensure that your tweet has above link and above 3 hashtags with CORRECT spellings - #CmAllStates #SscPaperExams #NoSscOnlineExams . You may copy my tweet from https://twitter.com/MehtaRahulC/status/970646906958475264 . Pls copy and NOT retweet, Because if my tweet is deleted, and if you have retweeted, then your tweet too may get deleted

(23) Pls share YOUR tweet on Facebook in a photo album called as “Law drafts I support”. Pls don’t share anywhere else on the wall, but ONLY in this public photo album. That is to ensure that in future, you can retrieve this post easily.

(24) Pls copy-paste THIS whole document on Facebook. And pls also share on WhatsApp

(25) As more people send the above tweet, chances that ---- SSC and other bodies will adopt paper based exam, where paper is printed in hall, all answers are immiditately uploaded on PUBLCI website, and students get copy --- will increase. At the end of the day, imo, you can ONLY increases chances,. I do NOT guarantee any success. And imo, only a liar will guarantee success and activism/politics.

Jai Hind

====

Added later

(18.1) The sysadmin and apex Minister\Chairman incharge can filterin cadnidates based on his caste/religious bias if they wish to.