Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
( incomplete , to be completed)
.
How Modiji (and SoGa/Arke) plan to further kill small manufacturers and small traders using eWayBill system.
.
(Pls confirm the information I am giving with a CA you know, because information about law is what I got from CAs I know, but they are not sure as law is still vague)
.
Here is how transport of goods work in USA. If a transporter is carrying any amount of goods -- except liquor, tabcaoo, firearms, petrol and some 10-15 items, then he need not declare goods or values while moving from any place to any place in same or different state. The policemen etc can stop him if there is complain and suspicion of THEFT. Tax is ONLY when goods are sold and later one has to pay income tax. But while moving goods, one doesnt need to pay tax or declare goods before moving
.
In Modiji's ewaybill system, seller , buyer or transporters - at least one of the three --- have to declare goods; ALL DETAILS including HSN codes and prices, before the shipment starts. The declaration is to be posted on GSTN website via PC or via android aap. And it must be posted before vehicle starts.
.
The best way to know a law is to know how fines are implemented and how officers have discretion to implement a fine
.
Now lets say a seller is selling formica (sheet we put on tables). The cost can be anywhere from Rs 1000 per sheet to Rs 10000 per sheet and it is highly negotiable depending on quantity, design etc. And sometimes, when seller wants to dispose the old and slightly DAMAGED stock, he may even sell at loss for half the price.
.
Now say seller is sending say 40 sheets which he thinks are valued at Rs 40000 . Since value is below Rs 50000, he decides not to make eWayBill. Now if the officer stops the vehicle, and if the officer decides that the value of formica sheets is Rs 60000 , then fines are as follows
.
(1) Rs 10000 fine MINIMUM for false valuation (if if discrepency is Re 1, fines min fine is Rs 10000)
.
(2) Twice the GST that officer things was evaded --- so it will be Rs 20000 of price difference * 18% * 2 = Rs 7200
.
And many more clauses may apply.
.
IOW, fines are so steep, that one will have to keep eWayBills.
.