Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

Bank Transaction Tax hoax
.
BTT people will show you RBI data on cheque and epayments. It is Rs 15 lak crore per DAY. So they say
.
GoI needs Rs 30 crore as expense (center / state / local)
.
Total bank transactions = Rs 15 lakh crore per day * 365 = about 5400 lakh crore per year
.
So transaction tax rate needed = 30 / 5400 = about 0.5%
.
The above calculations IGNORE the facts that
.
(1) Many transactions are bank to bank
.
(2) Many transactions are govt to govt
.
(3) many transactions are when person is paying tax to GoI or collecting refunds
,
(4) many transactions are PERSON to SAME PERSON i.e. I transfer money from my Bank of India main account to SBI once every 2 months.
.
(5) Many transactions are between family members
.
(6) Many transactions are share market and bond market transactions eg person buys commercial papers and then paper gets repaid in 7 to 30 days
.
The real transactions, in which material or land is moving - is only a small fraction.
.
BTT taxes real activity such as manufacturing and levies zero tax on land hoarding !! So much for argument that BTT will promote industries !!
.
Anil Bokiiji started BTT proposal in 1990s. It has been over 20 years. And he still has NOT given any DRAFT .
.
BTT is a nonsense proposal
.
Their goal is to block activists from taking interest in REAL proposals like Wealth tax so that proposals like GST can move ahead
.
---
.
Essentially, there are financial transactions and non financial transactions. Financial transactions are where money is moving, but there is no material moving below. And matrial or non-financial transactions are when material or land is moving along with money. eg say X buys vegetables for Rs 100 and so some material moved. But say Central Govt paid Rs 1000 crore to some State Govt. Then material moved = 0. A bordeline case is interest on loans - X loans Rs 1 lakh to Y and Y gives Rs 1.03 lakh after 1 month, where Rs 3000 was interest. Here material moved = 0, money moved = Rs 2.03 lakhs. But there was risk - and so one can take Rs 3000 as cost of risk or value of some material wealth generated from loan.