Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
Lets see some fines that trader or manufacturer or service provider will have to pay for some errors - be deliberate or accidents
.
----------
.
(1) Say a software maker's revenue is Rs 1.65 lakh per month i.e. just below Rs 20 lakh per year. Say he decided to remain as unregistered. Now say in on 1-oct-2017, he sent some software worth say Rs 50000 to someone outside India by email. Now GST on software export = 0% anyway. So evasion = Rs 0. And say he got cheque in his own name and deposited that in his own savings account. And say he shows all on books. Say GST officers catch his "crime" in april-2018. Now software has GST rate of 18% .
.
The GST law will assume him as registered regular i.e. non composite (18%) dealer since 1-oct-2018. So on his sale of july-aug-sep, there will be no GST. But for ALL his interstate local trade of oct to march = Rs 1.65 * 6 = around Rs 10 lakhs, he will taxed at 18%. So he needs to pay tax of Rs 180,000 !! And he needs to pay Rs 3000 * 6 = Rs 18000 or may be more for not filing returns. And he may need to pay 100% penalty on tax of Rs 180,000. And he may need to pay monthly 1.5% interest on GST that he "evaded" since 1-oct-2017 !!! Total crosses Rs 400,000 !! Now thats on sale of Rs 20 lakhs, not profit or income of Rs 20 lakhs
.
------
.
(2) Say a trader's revenue is Rs 1.65 lakh per month i.e. just below Rs 20 lakh per year. Say he decided to remain as unregistered. Now say in on 1-oct-2017, he sent goods worth say Rs 50000 to someone outside state by courier. And say he shows all on books. Say GST officers catch his crime in april-2018. Say goods he is selling have GST rate of 18% as most goods do.
.
The GST law will assume him as registered regular i.e. non composite (18%) dealer since 1-oct-2018. So on his sale of july-aug-sep, there will be no GST. But for ALL his local trade of oct to march = Rs 1.65 * 6 = around Rs 10 lakhs, he will taxed at 18%. So he needs to pay tax of Rs 180,000 !! And he needs to pay Rs 3000 * 6 = Rs 18000 or may be more for not filing returns. And he may need to pay 100% penalty on tax of Rs 180,000. And he may need to pay monthly 1.5% interest on GST that he "evaded" since 1-oct-2017 !!! Total crosses Rs 400,000 !! Now thats on sale of Rs 20 lakhs, not profit or income of Rs 20 lakhs
.
So if that unregistered delear, whether deliberately or accidentalty, sells Rs 50000 export or even Re 1 export, then a HUGE GST and penalty will apply on ALL his local software sales even if all was below Rs 20 lakhs !!
.
Many small software makers take contract from internet and thus they have export earnings. They will get royally shafted in april-2018, when GST officers review all dollar deposits across all banks.
.
----------
.
(3) Say a trader's revenue is Rs 6.20 lakh per month i.e. just below Rs 75 lakh per year. Say he decided to remain as composite. Now say in on 1-oct-2017, he sent goods worth say Rs 50000 to someone outside state by courier. And say he shows all on books. Say GST officers catch his "crime" in april-2018. Say goods he is selling have GST rate of 18% as most goods do.
.
The GST law will assume him as registered regular i.e. non composite (18%) dealer since 1-oct-2018. So on his sale of july-aug-sep, there will be no GST. But for ALL his local trade of oct to march = Rs 6.2 * 6 = around Rs 37 lakhs, he will taxed at 18%. So he needs to pay tax of about Rs 650,000 !! And he needs to pay Rs 3000 * 6 = Rs 18000 or may be more for not filing returns for six months. And he may need to pay 100% penalty on tax of Rs 650,000. And he may need to pay monthly 1.5% interest on GST that he "evaded" since 1-oct-2017 !!! Total crosses Rs 13 lakhs !! Now thats on sale of Rs 75 lakhs, not profit or income of Rs 75 lakhs
.
So if that composite delear, whether deliberately or accidentalty, sells Rs 50000 interstate or even Re 1 interstae, then a HUGE GST and penalty will apply on ALL his local sales even if all was below Rs 75 lakhs !!
.
-------------
.
(4) Say a farmer of State-A sells his own farm products in state-B. Even if goods are 0% GST, he will have to pay fine for NOT registering himself, not filing returns etc
.
----------
.
(5) Say a cow owner is selling milk of Rs 25 lakhs a year and ghee of Rs 1 lakh per year. Milk is 0% GST and ghee is 5% GST. But total exceeds Rs 20 lakhs. So he needs registration - composite or regular. And file 37 returns a year (now 10 returns a year). If he doesnt, then when caught after a year, he will have to pay Rs 5000 on sale of ghee and pay Rs 36000 or more for not filing returns !!!
.
------
.
I can give countless more examples
.
In income tax and wealth tax, penalties are ONLY proportional to taxes evaded. And return filing is once a year. eg I dont pay quarterly taxes and pay taxes only at year end. So whats the penatlty? 18% interest on TAXES due each quarter, not some huge sum on whole gross income.
.
All in all, it clear that purpose of GST is NOT to collect taxes, but to crush small / medium manufacturers , traders etc. There are so many points where they will make mistake, and each mistake will cost arm and leg.
.
Suffices to say ---- the goal of GST is NOT to collect taxes but to crush small / medium business and traders so that large can grow by taking over their businesses. If goal was to collect taxes, then leaders would have FIRST taxed land and wealth, rather than chasing each and every sale.