Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
RBI collected data 3000 private non-financial companies Between nov-jun. Their survey shows --- small companies suffered MUCH MUCH more large companies due to demo and pre-GST transition !!! And some very large companies profitted heavily !! And sum total went down.
.
The analysis doesnt cover imports, But foreign companies benefited MOST , because local manufacturing was disrupted and so many had to use imports more
.
Thats what I had said on nov-2016 , that smaller a company / person, more damage he will face due to Demo. And pre-GST transition cause same effect
.
Transition part's losses are inevitable and will vanish in long run. But question is --- once GST stabilizes by dec-2017, whom will it favor? My analysis says --- smaller a company, more it will suffer and reason is NOT technical inefficiency or economic inefficiency , but GST law's missing trader problem and double taxation on small traders problem makes it worse for small firms.
.
Pls read the whole article. EVERY line is raw data from RBI and worth reading.
.
And real music will only now start. Right now, GSTN has only started taking invoice details and only 10% of July invoices are uploaded. By 30-nov-2017, companies will finish uploading all july invoices, and GSTN will generate missing trader notices !!! By 31-dec-2017 end, there will LAKHS of missing trader notices all over !!
.
http://indianexpress.com/article/business/business-others/small-firms-flounder-post-demonetisation-on-gst-rbi-study-4815333/.
- https://indianexpress.com/article/business/business-others/small-firms-flounder-post-demonetisation-on-gst-rbi-study-4815333/
- https://external-dfw5-1.xx.fbcdn.net/emg1/v/t13/14976511102107103725?url=http%3A%2F%2Fimages.indianexpress.com%2F2017%2F07%2Frbi-7592.jpg%3Fw%3D759&fb_obo=1&utld=indianexpress.com&_nc_sid=c97757&_nc_ht=external-dfw5-1.xx.fbcdn.net&stp=c0.5000x0.5000f_dst-jpg_flffffff_p500x261_q75_tt6&ccb=18-1&_nc_gid=pjPe_Nb5yjWLngjOqwoLDQ&_nc_zt=3&oh=06_Q3_DAQhJbWcw4dXDjdZ58V7qkYH-aXVmNL0NiiP-jaPPYAJt&oe=6AC2FB07