Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate

Actual costs that RBI and Banks had to bear for notebandhi was much much higher than Rs 16000 crore that RBI "earned".
.
Also, Rs 16000 crore "earned" is NOT black. Some notes get lost or destroyed and they are defacto earning even with no notebandhi, And some notes were in Nepal, because they trusted us. And some notes were in Dubai and with NRIs across India. And yes, some money could have been black.
.
Now when notebandhi was done, I remember a retired bank clerk of mine , who had said that bank had called him for work, for some 10 days, and paid him some Rs 1500 per day !! And bank had to also hire temp peons and pay them some Rs 400 per day. Plus staff had to work, and banks had to compensate them indirectly.
.
The companies which put money in ATM had charged 50% for ATM filling, because the runs after 8 pm cost more. And ATM flling companies were not prepapred to do so many runs, and to hire more temp staff. And temp staff costs more.
.
And banks got flooded with deposits, and there were NO loan takers. So interest burden shot up.
.
So TOTAL costs that banks to bear was far more
.
And manufacturing had collapsed. The electricity consumption from nov-10 to nov-30 was some 15% to 20% less than same period in previous year. The vegetable and pulse prices had collapsed because buyers didnt have cash, and intermediate traders also didnt have cash. Endless stories of trade / manufacturing collapse.
.
Many poor were happy because they thought that rich lost big time !! This is a factor, which has often helped PSUEDO across the world --- they will take steps that will damage rich or it will appear that the steps have damaged rich, And poor dont benefit, but still many poor feel good about it.
.
Rashtravaadi leaders earned some Rs 50000 crore to Rs Rs 100000 crore (some say much more) in notebadli. Because all banks were under rashtravaadi leaders. The modus operandi was
.
(1) Catch and SBI or some PSU bank manager who has cases against him
.
(2) Ask him to co-operate or face stern action in those case. And he also gets 1% of note badli and staff gets 2%
.
(3) Say Apex Rashtravaadi leader gives say Rs 1 crore of cash of old notes to junior activist, who gives to bank manager, along with withdrawal cheques of account of local slum dwellers
.
(4) Old notes are deposirted in those accounts, and withdrawl of new notes is made,. Slum dwellers dont have to stand in queue.
.
(5) Slum dwellers get 5%, bank manager gets 1%, staff gets 2%, , junior activist keeps 5% and senior rashtravaadi leader keeps 25% and 65% go to the owner of the old notes
.
Then rashtravaadi helped rashtravaadi in UP elecitions and so on. Thats why, candidates supported by these rashtravaadi .leaders were able to spend 10-50 times more in newspaper advt !!
.
All in all notebandhi, was a great victory for "rashtravaadi" leaders.
.
----
.
Now GST will do another round of slaughter, Come december, and lakhs of traders / manufacturers will get notices that people whom they bought, have NOT paid GST !!! And so GST department will ask them to pay the GST amount once again !! And so many small / middle traders will start losing business. (right now, invoices are not filed, and each trader had to only pay whatever he thinks he is liable to pay).
.
Everything is going as SoGa / NaMo / ArKe and congress / rss / aap workers had planned, and promised to usuk-elitemen in around dec-2013. Each leader and workers were hungry for support of bikau mediamen like bikau arnab, bikau sardesai etc who live on money of usuk-elitemen money. And these elitemen wanted GST and other schemes that can ruin small / middle business. And so SoMoke and congress / rss / aap workers opposed wealth tax, and all supported GST !!