Rahul Mehta Gandhinagar LsCandidate
A fairy tale by paidjournalist to reduce depression of NaMo-andhbhagats --- Indian Military takes 1-2 helicopters some 10-20 km inside Pakistani border, drops 15-20 Indian soldiers by parachutes, and then Indian soldiers kill 20 terrorists and injure 200 more, and then helicopter airlifts all Indian soldiers and all Indian soldiers come back. No one left behind and no fatalities and no injuries.
This is the latest fairy tale by paidjournalist to reduce depression of NaMo-andhbhagats !!! And to give something to NaMo-andhbhagats to shout against SoGa/ArKe-andhbhagats and non-andhbhagats.
.
And yes, The NaMo-andhbhagats, like click robots on 11000 V have all started sharing this bold fairy tale !!!
.
The real news is --- NaMo's sponsors are paying huge money to assorted paidjournalist and self certified rightist bloggers to write and support this fairytale !!
.
----
.
Now lets look at how realistic such operation can be
,.
Lets take some real events. Indian Amry did take soldiers in helicopters and did a majr operation against terrorists in MYANMAR a few months back. But Myanmar govt had approved it !!! IOW, Myanmar Military had promised not to stop Indian soldiers. The enemy was some platoon of some 100-200 terrorists (not 1000s) who had killed some India soldiers a few days ago. and they were NOT aided by Myanmar Military.
.
Now in Pakistan, the whole Military is against India. And whole Loc is heavily guarded and supervised on both sides. Both sides have soldiers watching to ensure that they are no helicopters or vehicles or people going across.
.
And Pakistan has recently killed 17-20 Indian soldiers and injured many. So it is fears retaliation. And so supervision for helicopetsrm vehicles and persons would be much higher/
.
In all this supervision, 1-2 helicopter enter several kilimeters deep and dont get detected !!!
.
Now please google on MANPAD. Wiki pages will show how easy it is to shoot down a low flying helicoper once detected and in close range. see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Man-portable_air-defense_system and see
.
Now the soldiers in pakistan and terrorists in Pakistan have all such modern weapons like MANPADs. The missles of MANPADs are smart these days i.e. vene if helicoper changes route, the missile will change its route and target it.
.
Now the area is in POK, and has 100s of terrorists with guns and grenades, And more pakistani soldiers can come there at short notice. But they nevertheless, our soldiers landed, and also started shooting at Pakistanis. And Pakistanis did (must have) fire back but no Indian soldier got hurt. .
.
So our 20 men against 200 enemy men. All 220 have weapons. It is a level ground i.e. our soldiers dont have much advatange of height. The Pakistanis are behind makeshift walls and our soldiers are just behind trees and moving from one tree to another. Both sides throw grenades, 20 Pakistanis dies, 200 Pakistanis get injured and no casulties on our side.
.
Part-2 of this paidmediamen's fairy tale has more anti-depressant for NaMo-andhbhagats, The part-2 says that helicoper airlifted all soldiers back !!! To airlift, the helicoper has to fly low, and so it can get shot by MANPAD or even by shower of machines guns or rifle bullets. And while 20 soldiers got airlifted, and while pakistanis were showering machinegun and rifle bullets, none of our soldiers died. And helicopter too did NOT get shot !!!
/.
-----
.
Also note that our soldiers in Uri die because soldiers who wer sleeping in tents had kept their guns in nearby rooms. Basically, soldiers of Dogra regiment were moving out, and soldiers from other reghiment had reached 1-2 days early. And so there were more soldiers than rooms can accomodate and so some soldiers decided to sleep outside in tents. Now they left their luggage and guns in rooms, and went to tent. So when terrorists attacked, then did not have guns right next to them. and before they can reach their rooms, they got shot.
.
But Pakistanis terrorists inside PoK are now aware of possible retaliation. So they will all sleep with guns next to them. So Indian para soldiers will not get that even that advantage.
.
-----
.
Now if our chopper went all the way inside PoK, then it could have just thrown a few large bombs and missiles on tents or huts where terrorists sleep.
.
Why paradrop soldiers? Paradropping is needed when there is hostage situation or search and rescue OR when several of enemies are scattered over large area covered by trees and so taking helicoper everywhere isnt possible because helicoper can get shot by some MANPAD.
.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Para_(Special_Forces)
.
see also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paratrooper
..
But here enemies were sleeping is cluster of tents. And the goal was only to kill terrorists and some some search and rescue. So why send men down on feet? The chopper can throw bombs and come back.
.
-----
.
And if it is so possible to send helicopter without getting hit, and so easy for men to land, kill 20-30 enemies. then I wonder why Pakistani terrorists never brought helicopter to do their operations in India !!! Why do they travel all the way across tricky valleys and mountains, and forests and sometimes walk / swim across small river streams? The Pakistani terrorists are well funded enough to buy helicopters,. And if we can send a helicoper and have plausible denial, then so can Pakistani govt.
.
So pls do google "paradropping". You will see that in foreign enemy area , where 100-200 terrorists are living, and 100 pakistani soldiers can come from near by at short notice, paradropping 15-20 soldiers is not just unwise, it is suicidal.
.
The 4 Pakistani terrorists did kill out 15-20 soldiers in Uri. But how many could go back"? None. Return fire would be heavy and lethal. And they could kill 15-20 soldiers because soldiers were unaware and fire did more damage than bullets, Such fire is act of chance.
.
-------------------
.
All all in all, this seems that NaMo-sponsors have airdopped several lakh rupees to some paidjournalists on their payrools to cook, forward and support this fairytale. And it is necessary to reduce depression of NaMo-andhbhagats and also give them something to shout at SoGa-andhbhagats and ArKe-andhbhagats, and non-andhbhagats,
.
==============
.
Added later
.
Questions to those claim that "our 15 para-commandos enetered Pakistan and killed 20 Pakistani terrorists "
.
To the best of your information and opinions, pls say
.
1) To the best of your information and opinions, pls say --- approx how many kilometers approx did Indian Army helicopters went inside PoK?
.
2) To the best of your information and opinions, pls say--- has helicopter landed on land or come close to land say just 5 feet to 15 feet high, and then soldiers had jumped? Or was heliocpter flying several 100 feet high and soldiers had used parachute to land
.
3) To the best of your information and opinions, pls say ---- Did helicopters dropped soldiers right near the terrorist camp or did it drop some 200 meters to 500 meters sway and then soldiers had to walk 200 meters to 500 meters on feet to the camp?
,
4) To the best of your information and opinions, pls say--- when how high was helicopter when soldiers were being airlifted?
.
I request all NaMo-andhbhagats to get answers to these Qs asap. Because non-NaMo-andhbhagats believe that such operation is SUICIDAL (and so impossible i.e. i.e. no General will approve it), and so it did NOT happen. Please note --- doubt is NOT because that it was not done, the doubt is because -- this is too suicidal. So pls at least show how it can be done, assuming that pakistais after waking up did use at least AK-47s and also possibly MANPADs,.
.
==========
.
One answer I got for Q1 to Q4 is --- answer to these Q will damage national security !!
.
Folks, if such operation happened, the Pakistani generals know how it happened. I am NOT asking for pre-facto reporting or live reporting that can do damage. If such operation happened, then giving post-factor details add NO information to what Pakistani generals have. So by answering Q1 to Q4, there is no damage to India and no benefit to enemies.